Key Takeaways
- If you have underpaid tax, make a voluntary disclosure to HMRC promptly rather than wait for it to identify the error.
- Disclose before an HMRC enquiry, compliance check or relevant information request to preserve unprompted status and lower potential penalties.
- Correct a Self Assessment error within the amendment window through an amended return. Otherwise, choose the disclosure route that matches the tax.
- Use the Digital Disclosure Service for income tax, capital gains tax and certain offshore matters, but obtain advice before responding to the Contractual Disclosure Facility.
- Tax and interest remain payable. An agreed time-to-pay arrangement may permit instalments but does not stop interest accruing.
- Seek urgent solicitor-led advice where deliberate conduct, false records, offshore concealment, an HMRC enquiry or accountant error could create wider risks.
- Go Legal is rated Excellent with over 300 five-star reviews and 5/5 on Trustpilot and Google, placing our solicitors among the best-reviewed litigation lawyers in England and Wales.
Which HMRC Voluntary Disclosure Route Should You Use for Underpaid Tax?
The right route depends on three things: the tax involved, whether HMRC has already contacted you, and whether your disclosure is unprompted or prompted. Waiting for HMRC to find the error increases scrutiny and reduces the penalty reductions available to you.
The options include a Self Assessment amendment, the Digital Disclosure Service, VAT corrections, PAYE and CIS corrections, offshore disclosures and the Contractual Disclosure Facility. Choosing the wrong one, or sending incomplete information, can cost you penalty mitigation and expose you to wider risk.
Our London-based tax dispute solicitors assess the position before you contact HMRC, particularly where deliberate conduct, an enquiry, offshore income or an accountant’s error may be involved.
When You Must Disclose Underpaid Tax to HMRC
You should tell HMRC about underpaid tax as soon as you identify an incorrect return, undeclared income or unpaid tax. Discovering the error creates an obligation to notify HMRC promptly, even if the deadline for amending the return has passed. You remain responsible for the accuracy of returns submitted to HMRC, including returns prepared by an accountant.
The correct disclosure route depends on five factors:
- Whether HMRC has already contacted you.
- The tax involved, such as Self Assessment, PAYE, VAT or Corporation Tax.
- The affected tax years or accounting periods.
- Whether the error resulted from reasonable care, carelessness or deliberate conduct.
- Whether records, invoices or other evidence create wider risk.
| Common trigger | Typical issue to investigate | Possible route |
|---|---|---|
| Side income | Income above the Trading Allowance (which changes from April 2027) omitted from a Self Assessment return | Return amendment or voluntary disclosure |
| Rental income | Rent, expenses or property gains omitted | Return amendment or voluntary disclosure |
| Capital gains | Sale of shares, property or other assets not reported correctly | Return amendment or voluntary disclosure |
| Offshore income or assets | Overseas interest, income, gains or assets not disclosed | Worldwide Disclosure Facility |
| PAYE or CIS errors | Payroll deductions or construction industry returns are incorrect | PAYE or CIS correction |
| IR35 or employment-status errors | Contractors may have been treated incorrectly for tax purposes | Employment-status disclosure |
| VAT errors | VAT has been underpaid or overclaimed | VAT return adjustment or written notification |
| Accountant error | An adviser used incomplete information or made a calculation error, and you signed the return | Correct the tax position and preserve evidence |
An accountant preparing the return does not remove your responsibility for what you signed. The accountant’s error may support a separate claim against them, but HMRC still expects you to correct the position.
Unprompted vs Prompted Disclosures: Why Timing Matters
An unprompted disclosure is made when you have no reason to believe HMRC has discovered, or is about to discover, the inaccuracy. Any other disclosure is prompted. HMRC’s Compliance Handbook states the test this way: “A disclosure is unprompted if it is made at a time when the person making it has no reason to believe that we have discovered or are about to discover the inaccuracy or under-assessment.”
HMRC treats this as an objective, fact-sensitive question. It is not simply about who writes first. A disclosure can remain unprompted even if you do not yet know the full scale of the problem, provided you supply full details within a reasonable time.
Contact that may make a disclosure prompted includes:
- An HMRC enquiry or compliance check.
- An information request.
- A request for bank statements, invoices or payroll records.
- Targeted correspondence about a particular source of income.
- A nudge letter or campaign invitation connected to the tax issue.
The distinction matters because it changes the penalty range. Under Schedule 24 Finance Act 2007, the penalty ranges for inaccurate returns, as a percentage of the tax underpaid, are:
- Careless behaviour: 0 to 30% unprompted, 15 to 30% prompted.
- Deliberate behaviour: 20 to 70% unprompted, 35 to 70% prompted.
- Deliberate and concealed behaviour: 30 to 100% unprompted, 50 to 100% prompted.
For careless errors, only an unprompted disclosure can reduce the penalty to nil.
Three mistakes commonly turn a position that started unprompted into a prompted one:
- Delaying after HMRC correspondence. Sitting on a nudge letter or compliance campaign invitation that relates to the error gives HMRC grounds to say discovery was coming.
- Disclosing part of the picture and then waiting. Leaving other years or income streams unexplained undermines the requirement to provide full details within a reasonable time.
- Disclosing after HMRC requests documents connected to the inaccuracy. Once HMRC asks for the bank statements or invoices that would reveal the problem, the disclosure is unlikely to be treated as unprompted.
If HMRC has already opened an enquiry or compliance check, a disclosure through a campaign route is unlikely to be accepted. The disclosure should instead be made to the HMRC officer handling the enquiry. Our solicitors can review the correspondence, assess whether your disclosure can still be treated as unprompted and identify the risks before any response is sent.
How to Make a Voluntary Disclosure: Routes and Process
The right route depends on the tax type, the period affected and whether the issue involves deliberate behaviour. Work through it in this order:
- Identify every affected tax, return, accounting period and source of income.
- Check whether the return can still be amended through the normal process.
- Establish whether HMRC has made relevant contact.
- Match each error to the correct correction or disclosure route.
- Assess whether false records, offshore concealment or deliberate conduct require solicitor-led advice before anything is sent to HMRC.
Amending a tax return
Income for the year before the current tax year should generally go into a tax return rather than a disclosure. If that return has already been filed, it can be amended within 12 months of the statutory filing date. Errors outside that window require a separate written disclosure with calculations.
Paper Income Tax returns are generally due by 31 October following the end of the tax year. Online returns are generally due by 31 January. Company Tax Returns are generally due within 12 months of the end of the accounting period.
Outstanding Company Tax Returns for periods ending within the last four years should be filed, with income from earlier periods included in the disclosure.
The Digital Disclosure Service
The Digital Disclosure Service can be used by individuals and companies for Income Tax, Capital Gains Tax, Inheritance Tax, Corporation Tax, National Insurance contributions and Annual Tax for Enveloped Dwellings.
Offshore income, assets and gains go through the Worldwide Disclosure Facility, which forms part of the Digital Disclosure Service. You sign in, provide details of the case, calculate tax, interest and penalties, submit supporting documents and make a formal offer.
HMRC’s online calculator covers tax years up to 5 April 2024. Older or more complicated matters may require separate calculations and professional review.
VAT, PAYE, CIS and employment status
VAT errors cannot be put through the Digital Disclosure Service. Some can be corrected by adjusting a VAT return, subject to the applicable conditions. Where those conditions are not met, the error must be notified in writing, including by form VAT 652.
Employers may need to correct PAYE and CIS returns for the current and previous six tax years. For employment-status and off-payroll working errors, HMRC expects each affected worker’s name and National Insurance number, job title, the dates the issue arose, Income Tax and National Insurance calculations, and Apprenticeship Levy figures where relevant.
PAYE underpayments discovered by HMRC are normally collected by adjusting the tax code for the following year. You should check HMRC’s calculation and notify it if the figures or liability period are incorrect.
The Contractual Disclosure Facility
The Contractual Disclosure Facility (CDF) is reserved for suspected serious fraud, where deliberate behaviour has caused HMRC a loss of tax, duty, levy or payment. Deliberate behaviour includes knowing tax was owed but choosing not to tell HMRC, or knowing figures in a return were wrong when it was submitted.
HMRC issues a CDF offer letter. If you enter the CDF contract and make a complete and accurate disclosure of all deliberate behaviour that caused the loss, HMRC states that it will not open a criminal investigation into that disclosure.
The CDF is the only disclosure route that gives this assurance. It depends entirely on the disclosure being complete and accurate. Specialist legal advice is essential before accepting or responding to a CDF offer.
Calculating Tax, Interest and Penalties in 2026
Tax, interest and penalties are three separate elements of an HMRC disclosure, and each must be calculated correctly.
Tax: The underlying tax is calculated using the rules and rates that applied in the relevant year or accounting period. Correcting an old error does not mean current rates apply.
Interest: Interest runs from the date the tax was due until the date it is paid, calculated daily. It is not negotiable and remains payable however promptly you disclose. HMRC may reject a disclosure that does not include the correct interest.
Late-payment interest increased in November 2026 after the Bank of England base rate rose to 4.00% on 5 November 2026. The statutory formula is base rate plus 4%, giving a current HMRC late-payment rate of 8.00%.
Penalties: Penalties may apply where you submitted an incorrect return or failed to notify HMRC of a tax liability. They are calculated as a percentage of the additional tax and can reach 100% for income or gains arising in the United Kingdom and 200% for offshore liabilities.
The percentage depends on:
- Your behaviour: reasonable care, careless, deliberate, or deliberate and concealed.
- Whether the disclosure was prompted or unprompted.
- The quality of your disclosure: telling HMRC about the problem, helping it establish the tax due and giving access to evidence and records.
A taxpayer who took reasonable care may not pay a penalty at all, although HMRC says it does not expect many cases to fall into that category.
How Far Back HMRC Can Investigate
How far back HMRC can go depends on your behaviour. The standard assessment window is four years from the end of the tax year for innocent errors and mistakes made despite taking reasonable care.
It extends to six years where the taxpayer failed to take reasonable care, and to 20 years for deliberate behaviour. Offshore matters involving income, gains or assets can extend the window to 12 years for careless behaviour and 20 years for deliberate behaviour.
A voluntary disclosure does not shorten these periods. It does allow you to present a complete explanation, supporting records and calculations before HMRC draws its own conclusions about your behaviour, which determines both the investigation window and the penalty.
Budget 2026 announced new requirements for taxpayers to correct returns and other documents when inaccuracies are identified. The measures are intended to take effect from 1 April 2028, subject to legislation, and signal the direction HMRC is taking.
HMRC is also strengthening its compliance approach for wealthy taxpayers and modernising its compliance activity. Accurate, contemporaneous records and well-documented disclosures matter more as a result. Keep records that explain both the figures and how the error happened, including previous returns, accounting records, emails with advisers, bank statements, invoices, property records and payroll documents.
What Happens After You Disclose
HMRC will usually acknowledge the disclosure, issue a reference number and review the calculations, explanation and supporting documents. Full co-operation with follow-up questions is a condition of using the disclosure opportunity.
HMRC may ask for bank statements, invoices and accounts, property income records, payroll information, evidence supporting deductions or expenses, further calculations, or a meeting.
The 90-day Digital Disclosure Service timetable
The Digital Disclosure Service process has five stages:
- Notify HMRC of your intention to disclose.
- Disclose all previously undeclared income, gains, tax and duties.
- Make a formal offer.
- Pay what is owed.
- Co-operate with further information requests.
You must submit the disclosure within 90 days of the date HMRC acknowledges your notification. Payment must also reach HMRC within that period unless payment arrangements were agreed before you submitted the disclosure.
The formal offer carries real weight. Your offer, together with HMRC’s acceptance letter, creates a legally binding contract, often called a contract settlement, confirming the tax, interest and penalties due. It should not be signed without understanding the admissions it covers.
If a disclosure turns out to be substantially wrong or incomplete, HMRC may seek higher penalties and, in exceptional circumstances, consider the matter under its criminal investigation policy.
If you cannot pay
Contact HMRC as soon as possible and before submitting the disclosure. HMRC may ask for details of your income, expenditure, assets and liabilities before considering a payment arrangement. An arrangement helps cash flow but does not stop interest accruing or reduce penalties.
If HMRC disputes your figures
Where HMRC disputes the calculations or your behaviour classification, you can provide further evidence or request an internal review. If settlement cannot be reached, you may appeal to the First-tier Tribunal (Tax). Legal representation is advisable once the figures, behaviour or penalty are disputed, and our solicitors handle HMRC tax disputes and First-tier Tribunal appeals.
Common Mistakes and When to Seek Legal Advice
The most damaging disclosure mistakes usually happen before the first explanation reaches HMRC.
Disclosing too little: Omitting tax years, income streams or liabilities in the hope HMRC will not ask is a serious risk. Omitted years HMRC later discovers are treated as prompted, and the omission itself can indicate deliberate behaviour.
Using the wrong route: Putting a matter involving deliberate conduct through the Digital Disclosure Service when it requires the CDF, or approaching the CDF without advice, can forfeit penalty reductions. It can also mean handing HMRC evidence of fraud without the protection of legal professional privilege.
Assuming the accountant’s error ends your responsibility: It does not. Keep the engagement letter, correspondence, draft returns, source records and advice you received. These documents explain how the error arose and may support a professional negligence claim against an accountant or tax adviser, depending on the retainer, loss suffered and limitation position.
Seek legal advice before disclosing where:
- HMRC has opened an enquiry or requested documents.
- The facts may involve deliberate evasion, false invoices or altered records.
- Offshore income, assets or gains are involved.
- The sums are substantial.
- A company’s tax position has triggered director and shareholder disputes involving tax liabilities.
- The error arose from professional advice and you are considering a negligence claim.
Communications with a solicitor can be protected by legal professional privilege. This allows you to investigate sensitive facts and take advice before giving HMRC a detailed narrative. Communications with an accountant may not receive the same protection.
How Our Solicitors Approach HMRC Voluntary Disclosures
Go Legal is a London-based commercial litigation law firm acting for individuals, directors, professionals and businesses across England and Wales. Our solicitors handle an HMRC voluntary disclosure in a deliberate order:
- Assess whether HMRC contact makes the disclosure prompted or whether it can remain unprompted.
- Identify the correct correction or disclosure route for each tax liability.
- Review the records and establish the full factual position before any narrative is submitted.
- Advise on deliberate-conduct and criminal-risk issues before any communication with HMRC.
- Prepare or review calculations, evidence schedules, formal offers and responses to HMRC requests.
- Challenge inaccurate calculations, behaviour classifications or penalties through review or appeal.
- Consider whether accountant or tax adviser error supports a professional negligence claim.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I make a voluntary disclosure to HMRC after HMRC has contacted me?
+−
Yes, but it will be treated as prompted if HMRC has sent a nudge letter, compliance campaign invitation or information request relating to the inaccuracy. A prompted disclosure attracts higher minimum penalties and lower maximum reductions. If HMRC has opened an enquiry or compliance check, the disclosure should go to the officer handling it rather than through a campaign route.
Will HMRC waive my penalty if I disclose underpaid tax first?
+−
Not automatically. For careless errors, an unprompted disclosure with full co-operation can reduce the penalty to nil, but tax and interest remain payable. Deliberate behaviour always attracts some penalty, although disclosing first and co-operating fully secures the lowest percentage within the statutory range. Where you took reasonable care, HMRC may not charge a penalty at all.
What should I do if my accountant made an error on my tax return?
+−
You still need to correct the position with HMRC, because responsibility for the return remains yours. Preserve emails, working papers, draft returns, source documents and the engagement letter. These help explain how the error occurred and may also be relevant to a negligence claim against the adviser if you suffered recoverable loss.
Can I pay HMRC tax disclosure liabilities in instalments?
+−
HMRC may agree a time-to-pay arrangement depending on the amount, your circumstances and your compliance history. Raise it before submitting the disclosure, with details of income, expenditure, assets and liabilities ready. Interest keeps running and penalties are not reduced, but an agreed arrangement can prevent immediate enforcement. Ignoring the debt risks enforcement action and additional costs.
Do I need a solicitor for the Contractual Disclosure Facility?
+−
The CDF involves formal admissions of deliberate behaviour, and HMRC’s assurance that it will not open a criminal investigation depends on the disclosure being complete and accurate. A solicitor can investigate the facts under legal professional privilege, identify everything that must be disclosed and manage the response to HMRC’s offer letter before anything is admitted.
What should I do if HMRC finds undeclared income before I disclose it?
+−
Do not ignore HMRC’s requests or give a partial explanation to buy time. Preserve the correspondence, identify the income and periods involved, and check whether other returns are affected. Where the sums are substantial, the conduct may be deliberate or the calculations are disputed, take legal advice before responding to HMRC.
Get Expert Help With Your HMRC Voluntary Disclosure
Discovering underpaid tax does not mean you should immediately send HMRC an informal explanation. A complete, carefully prepared disclosure made promptly may reduce penalties. Delay, partial information or the wrong route can turn a correctable error into a prompted disclosure, a higher penalty and, where deliberate conduct is involved, a risk of criminal investigation.
Our tax dispute solicitors advise individuals, directors and businesses across England and Wales on voluntary disclosures, HMRC enquiries, penalty challenges and serious cases involving offshore assets or suspected deliberate conduct. We assess your position, protect privilege and prepare the calculations and evidence before you communicate with HMRC. Call us on 0207 459 4037 or book a free consultation today.
















