Key Takeaways
- Apply within one month of the bill being delivered and the court must order an assessment, without you having to prove solicitor overcharging first.
- After one month, the court decides whether to order assessment and on what terms. After 12 months, you must show special circumstances.
- Paying the bill changes your position, so take advice before any payment, part-payment or settlement.
- As a general rule, a solicitor cannot sue for unpaid fees until one month has passed from compliant delivery of a statute bill.
- An estimate is not automatically a cap, but it is evidence of what it was reasonable for you to pay.
- If the bill is reduced by 20% or more, the client normally receives the costs of the assessment, so the percentage reduction matters as much as the saving.
- A Legal Ombudsman complaint deals with poor service. A section 70 assessment decides whether the fees themselves are reasonable.
- Go Legal is rated Excellent with over 300 five-star reviews and 5/5 on Trustpilot and Google, placing our solicitors among the best-reviewed litigation lawyers in England and Wales.
Can I Challenge My Solicitor’s Bill for Overcharging Under Section 70?
Yes. In England and Wales, solicitor overcharging can be challenged through a solicitor-client assessment under section 70 of the Solicitors Act 1974, where the court decides what the bill should properly be. If you apply within one month of the bill being delivered, you have an unconditional right to that assessment.
Common triggers include a bill far above the estimate, a single figure for “professional fees” with no breakdown, and charges for work you never authorised. A poor result in your case does not, on its own, prove the fees are unreasonable. That is usually a separate service or negligence issue with its own remedy.
The same rules matter to law firms. A solicitor chasing an unpaid bill needs a compliant statute bill, clear delivery evidence and records supporting each charge before issuing proceedings. Our solicitors act both for clients challenging bills and for firms defending assessments.
What Laws and Deadlines Apply to Challenging a Solicitor’s Bill?
The timetable is set by section 70 of the Solicitors Act 1974, and every deadline runs from the date the bill was delivered.
| When the application is made | Position under section 70 |
|---|---|
| Before one month has expired from delivery of the bill | The court must order assessment without requiring payment into court, and no action may be started on the bill until the assessment is complete. |
| After one month but before 12 months | The court may order assessment on terms it considers appropriate. |
| After 12 months | The applicant must show special circumstances. |
These limits are not technicalities. In Bidzina Ivanishvili v Signature Litigation LLP [2023] EWHC (SCCO) 2189, the court described section 70 as giving a client a statutory right to apply for assessment, with time limits by which that right may be lost.
What Happens If I Apply During the Automatic Assessment Window?
If you apply before one month has passed from delivery, the court must order the assessment. You do not need to prove overcharging first. The Supreme Court confirmed this in Oakwood Solicitors Ltd v Menzies [2024] UKSC 34:
“For one month after its delivery there is an unconditional right to have the bill assessed.”
The month runs from delivery. It does not run from when you first queried the bill, started negotiating or received a reminder. An application within that month also stops the solicitor from starting a claim on the bill until the assessment is complete.
What Happens If I Challenge My Solicitor’s Bill Later?
After the first month, the court decides whether to order an assessment and on what terms. A late application should set out the bill and its delivery date, the specific issues in dispute and the evidence supporting each one. After 12 months, Oakwood Solicitors Ltd v Menzies confirms that special circumstances are required.
Can I Challenge a Solicitor’s Bill After It Has Been Paid?
Possibly, but payment changes the position. Delivery and payment are different legal events, and a bill may be delivered long before it is paid. In Oakwood Solicitors Ltd v Menzies, the Supreme Court confirmed that stricter rules apply once the bill has been paid, including the effect of section 70(4). Take advice before treating a part-payment, a settlement or a payment made under pressure as the end of the dispute.
Can Someone Other Than the Client Apply?
Sometimes. Under section 71, a third party may apply as if that person were the party chargeable with the bill, and the court can make any order it could have made on the client’s own application. This can matter where, for example, a parent company, an insurer or a family member paid fees for work done for someone else.
What Grounds Can Support a Challenge to Unreasonable Solicitor Fees?
Unreasonable solicitor fees are challenged by testing the bill against the retainer, the work the matter actually required and the evidence behind each charge. A general sense that the total is too high is rarely enough on its own.
Can I Challenge an Excessive Hourly Rate or Too Much Time Recorded?
Yes. A high hourly rate does not automatically make a bill excessive. The questions are whether the rate was agreed, whether the work needed that level of seniority and whether the recorded time was reasonably spent. Look for:
- hourly rates that differ from the retainer or client-care letter;
- senior fee earners doing routine tasks;
- several entries recording the same work;
- repeated reviews, duplicated attendance or unexplained internal discussions;
- time that is out of proportion to the importance and complexity of the matter.
A concern carries far more weight when tied to a specific entry, instruction or document.
Can I Challenge Work That Was Unauthorised or Unnecessary?
Yes, where the charge falls outside what you agreed. The retainer should define the work the solicitor was instructed to do and who could authorise extra spending, such as counsel’s fees, expert costs and other disbursements. Ask whether each charge fell within scope, whether authority was obtained and whether the bill explains why the money was spent. A firm defending a challenge should be able to produce the instructions, approvals and work records.
Does the Retainer or Fee Agreement Affect the Bill?
Yes, and a missing or unclear retainer makes the dispute harder to resolve. Without clear terms, there may be uncertainty about the hourly rates, the scope of work, authority to incur disbursements and whether a figure was an estimate or a fixed fee. Emails, attendance notes and costs updates written at the time then become the key evidence.
If you signed a conditional fee agreement, damages-based agreement or contentious business agreement, read it as a contract first. Its wording may decide which charges were agreed, what triggers payment and whether additional sums can be claimed. Disputes about success fees and percentage-based fees often turn on precise drafting.
Can a Solicitor Charge More Than an Estimate or Fixed Fee?
Sometimes. An estimate is not automatically a cap. A fixed fee or quote may have a different contractual effect, depending on its wording and the agreed scope of work.
In Wong v Vizards [1997] 2 Costs LR 46, the court treated the solicitors’ estimate, and the client’s reliance on it, as relevant to how much it was reasonable for the client to pay. The sum allowed equated to the estimate plus 15%.
Later cases make clear this is not a fixed formula:
- Mastercigars Direct Ltd v Withers LLP states that Wong does not establish a general rule capping costs at an estimate plus a margin.
- Emmanouil Spanakis v Schillings International LLP [2025] EWHC 873 confirms that substantially exceeding an estimate does not automatically bind the solicitor to it. The estimate is a matter the court takes into account when assessing reasonableness.
What Is a Statute Bill and Can a Defective Bill Be Enforced?
A statute bill is a solicitor’s bill that meets the formal requirements of section 69 of the Solicitors Act 1974, which governs court claims to recover solicitor’s costs.
In Daniel Kenig v Thomson Snell & Passmore LLP [2024] EWCA Civ 15, the Court of Appeal confirmed that section 69 sets formal requirements for a statutory bill. It also confirmed that, under section 69(1), the general rule is that a claim to recover costs cannot be brought until one month has passed from compliant delivery of the bill to the person chargeable.
What Should a Statute Bill Contain?
In practice, a statute bill should:
- be signed by the solicitor or on the firm’s behalf;
- be delivered to the client or other person liable to pay;
- give enough detail of the work done for that person to understand the charges and decide whether to seek assessment;
- show the amount due.
To test the detail, compare the bill with the retainer, earlier invoices, estimates and costs updates, time records, and counsel, expert and other third-party invoices.
What Problems Commonly Arise?
The most frequent problems are a single figure for professional fees with no breakdown, vague work descriptions, unexplained disbursements and interim invoices whose wording and intended effect differ from a final bill. Delivery can also be disputed, for example where the bill went to an old address or email account. The delivery date matters both for any recovery claim and for the section 70 timetable.
What Should Clients and Solicitors Do If the Bill May Not Comply?
Clients should ask focused written questions rather than simply refusing to pay. Solicitors should review the retainer, billing history, delivery evidence and support for each significant charge before starting a recovery claim. A defect in the bill or its delivery can delay or undermine that claim.
How Do I Apply for a Solicitor-Client Detailed Assessment?
You apply to the court, supported by the bill, proof of delivery and the documents that explain the dispute. Government guidance states that a client can ask the Senior Courts Costs Office for a detailed assessment, and that the bill may be reduced if it is considered too expensive. The detailed assessment guidance identifies form N258C and a court fee, shown as £335 for a bill of £15,000 or less. Court fees are revised periodically, so the fee payable is the one in force on the day you file.
How Do I Prepare an Application Step by Step?
- Identify each bill in dispute and the date it was delivered.
- Work out whether you are in the first month, the later period or the special-circumstances stage.
- Collect the retainer, client-care letter, estimates, invoices and payment records.
- Prepare clear objections to the significant charges and disbursements.
- Complete the court application and follow any directions the court gives.
- Keep any negotiations focused on the disputed items, and keep all correspondence.
What Documents Will the Court Need?
The most useful documents are usually:
- the bill, invoice schedules and payment records;
- the retainer, client-care letter and terms of business;
- estimates, quotes, budgets and costs updates;
- correspondence about changes in scope or authority for extra work;
- time records and attendance notes;
- counsel’s fee notes, expert invoices and other disbursement documents.
What Happens During a Detailed Assessment?
The court assesses the solicitor’s bill and decides the amount allowed, considering the retainer, the work done, the sums claimed and both sides’ evidence. If the bill is unpaid, the assessment can reduce what you owe. If you have already paid, the result may show that you have overpaid.
Who Pays the Costs of a Solicitor-Client Assessment?
If the bill is reduced by 20% or more, the client will normally receive the costs of the assessment. In Wilsons Solicitors LLP v Bentine & Anor [2015] EWCA Civ 1168, the Court of Appeal confirmed this applies unless the costs judge finds special circumstances. Where the reduction falls short of 20%, the client will normally pay the solicitor’s costs of the assessment.
This cost-shifting rule cuts both ways. A firm whose bill is clearly excessive risks paying the reduction and the client’s assessment costs. A client whose objections are only marginal may win a reduction yet still bear the firm’s costs.
How Should Both Sides Weigh the Commercial Risk?
Before applying or defending, consider:
- the likely reduction, and whether it will reach 20%;
- the value of each disputed item;
- court fees and legal costs;
- the quality of the available documents;
- the scope for an agreed reduction.
When Is Settlement Better Than a Full Assessment?
Settlement often makes sense where the parties can identify the main disputed items and agree a revised figure without running up further costs. This is particularly relevant in substantial commercial disputes and litigation, where a disputed bill can affect a business well beyond the invoice itself.
Should I Use an Assessment, a Complaint, a Regulatory Report or a Negligence Claim?
Choose the route that matches the problem:
- A section 70 assessment asks the court to decide the proper amount of the bill. It is the direct remedy where a bill is too high, unclear or outside the agreed terms.
- A Legal Ombudsman complaint deals with poor service, such as delay, poor communication or inadequate costs information, usually after the firm’s own complaints procedure.
- A report to the Solicitors Regulation Authority may be appropriate where you are concerned about serious professional misconduct. The SRA is a regulator, not a fee arbitrator.
- A professional negligence claim seeks compensation for loss caused by negligent advice or representation. You may also find our guide on professional negligence claims against solicitors useful.
More than one route may apply. A client may challenge an excessive bill and also complain that the firm failed to warn them as costs rose. A complaint does not replace an assessment, though, and lengthy complaint correspondence can quietly use up the one-month window.
Frequently Asked Questions
Do I Have to Pay My Solicitor’s Bill Before Challenging It?
+−
No. If you apply within one month of delivery, the court must order assessment without requiring payment into court. After that, the court can set the terms on which assessment proceeds, which may include paying part of the bill. Paying in full can make a later challenge harder, so take advice before making any payment you do not accept is owed.
Can a Company Challenge Its Solicitor’s Bill?
+−
Yes. The company named in the retainer will usually be the relevant party, even if a director gave the instructions. Preserve board records, instructions, fee approvals, invoices and correspondence. Identify who had authority to agree changes in scope or extra spending, especially where several directors dealt with the firm and approvals may have been given informally.
Can I Challenge an Interim Solicitor’s Bill?
+−
Possibly. Interim bills need careful review because their wording and intended effect may differ from a final bill. Keep every interim invoice, payment record and costs update. The timing, delivery and status of each bill can affect which route is open under section 70, so treat each bill separately rather than waiting for the final account.
Can I Change Solicitors While I Dispute the Old Firm’s Fees?
+−
Yes, but plan the move carefully. Protect any live case first, identify the documents your new solicitors will need and keep the fee dispute separate from urgent steps in the underlying matter. A new legal team can review both the old bill and the immediate risks in your ongoing claim, so neither suffers while the dispute continues.
Can I Negotiate a Reduction Without Admitting the Bill Is Correct?
+−
Usually, yes. A settlement proposal can identify the disputed items and seek a commercial resolution without accepting that the full bill is reasonable. Keep the proposal and its supporting documents separate from routine correspondence, so the scope of any agreement is clear and nothing else is read as acceptance of the remaining charges.
What Happens If My Solicitor Starts a Court Claim for Unpaid Fees?
+−
Do not ignore it. Preserve the bill, retainer, delivery evidence, payment records and every objection you have raised. Get advice promptly on your defence, your assessment position under section 70 and any related negligence issues. Your options will depend heavily on when the bill was delivered, whether it complies with section 69 and whether any of it has been paid.
Speak to Our Solicitor Overcharging Team
The delivery date of your bill is the single most important fact in any challenge. Within the first month, assessment is yours as of right. After that, the court controls whether and on what terms the bill is assessed, and payment can narrow your options further. For firms, a defective bill or unclear delivery can stall recovery entirely.
Go Legal is a London-based commercial litigation firm acting for individuals, directors, professionals and businesses across England and Wales. Our solicitors review the bill, delivery evidence and section 70 timetable, analyse retainers, estimates, time records and disbursements, and give a commercial view of the likely saving against the costs risk. We act for clients challenging solicitor fees and for firms defending assessment applications, in negotiations and in court.
















