Key Takeaways
- A section 239 preference arises where a company’s transaction leaves a creditor, surety or guarantor better off than they would have been in an insolvent liquidation.
- A liquidator or administrator must establish three elements: a benefit to the recipient, the company’s inability to pay its debts (or insolvency caused by the transaction), and a desire to prefer.
- Payments to unconnected recipients can be challenged if made in the six months before the onset of insolvency. For connected persons such as directors, the period is two years.
- Repaying a director’s loan is not automatically a preference, but a connected recipient must rebut the presumption that the company was influenced by a desire to prefer them.
- Board minutes, emails, forecasts, bank records and creditor correspondence often decide whether a payment was driven by commercial pressure or by a wish to favour the recipient.
- If the claim succeeds, the court can order repayment, the return of property or the setting aside of security to restore the insolvency estate.
- Go Legal’s solicitors can assess the evidence, challenge an alleged desire to prefer and negotiate a commercially workable resolution.
- Go Legal is rated Excellent with over 300 five-star reviews and 5/5 on Trustpilot and Google, placing our solicitors among the best-reviewed litigation lawyers in England and Wales.
What Is a Section 239 Preference Claim Under the Insolvency Act 1986?
A section 239 preference claim challenges a transaction that put a creditor, surety or guarantor in a better position than they would have held if the company had gone into insolvent liquidation without it. Under section 239 of the Insolvency Act 1986, a liquidator or administrator can ask the court to reverse that advantage.
A payment is not safe simply because the creditor was genuinely owed the money. Section 239(4) asks a comparative question: where would the recipient stand in an insolvent liquidation if the transaction had never happened, and are they now better off? That comparison is the core of the test.
Definition: Insolvency law distributes the available assets fairly among creditors of the same class. This is the pari passu principle. A preference distorts that equality by improving one creditor’s recovery at the expense of the general body of creditors.
Can Repaying a Creditor, Granting Security or Reducing a Guarantor’s Exposure Be a Preference?
Yes. A preference can take several forms, including:
- Paying one creditor while others remain unpaid.
- Repaying a director’s loan account.
- Granting security for an existing unsecured debt.
- Transferring an asset to reduce a guarantor’s exposure.
- Paying HMRC while leaving trade creditors unpaid.
The transaction does not need to look like a preference when it happens. What matters is its practical effect if the company later enters insolvent liquidation.
Why Is a Preference Payment Not Automatically Unlawful?
Paying a genuine debt is not improper in itself. Trading companies make payments for valid commercial reasons every day.
The risk arises only where every statutory condition is met. The payment is assessed against the company’s financial position at the time, the recipient’s position in a hypothetical insolvency, and the reasons the decision-makers chose to make it.
How Do You Prove a Preference Claim Under the Insolvency Act?
A preference claim succeeds only if three separate elements are established: benefit, insolvency and desire. Each needs its own evidence, and a claim can fail on any one of them.
Pillar 1: How Do You Test Whether the Recipient Received an Insolvency Advantage?
The question is whether the creditor, surety or guarantor ended up better off than in an insolvent liquidation. This means comparing:
- What the recipient actually received through the transaction.
- What the recipient would have received if the transaction had not happened and the company had entered insolvent liquidation.
A payment improves an unsecured creditor’s position because it turns a debt that might have paid a few pence in the pound into cash. Security improves a creditor’s position because it gives priority over unsecured creditors. A transaction that reduces a guarantor’s personal exposure benefits the guarantor even though the money goes to someone else.
Pillar 2: How Do You Establish That the Company Was Unable to Pay Its Debts?
The company must have been unable to pay its debts within the meaning of section 123 of the Insolvency Act 1986 at the time of the preference, or have become unable to pay them as a result of it. Section 123 contains two main tests:
- Cash-flow insolvency: the company cannot pay its debts as they fall due.
- Balance-sheet insolvency: the value of the company’s assets is less than its liabilities, taking account of contingent and prospective liabilities.
Section 123 also contains a statutory-demand route, triggered where a debt exceeding £750 remains unpaid three weeks after service of a written demand. Most preference disputes, however, turn on the cash-flow and balance-sheet evidence at the date of the payment.
Pillar 3: What Does Desire to Prefer Mean for Directors and Decision-Makers?
Under section 239(5), the company must have been influenced in deciding to enter the transaction by a desire to put the recipient in a better position. This is a subjective test of the company’s state of mind. In practice, it means the thinking of the directors or others who took the decision.
The question is not whether the payment helped a creditor, but why the company decided to make it. For connected recipients, that desire is presumed. For unconnected creditors, the office-holder must prove it.
How Do the Relevant Periods Differ for Connected and Unconnected Recipients?
A connected recipient faces a two-year look-back period, while an unconnected recipient faces six months. Under section 240 of the Insolvency Act 1986, both periods end with the onset of insolvency.
| Connected recipient | Unconnected recipient | |
|---|---|---|
| Look-back period | Two years ending with the onset of insolvency | Six months ending with the onset of insolvency |
| Desire to prefer | Presumed unless the recipient proves otherwise | Office-holder must prove it |
| Typical recipients | Directors, shadow directors, their associates, associates of the company | Independent suppliers, lenders and trade creditors |
Both conditions are cumulative. The transaction must fall within the relevant period, and the company must have been unable to pay its debts at that time or have become unable to pay them because of the transaction.
Who Is a Connected Person for a Preference Claim?
Section 249 of the Insolvency Act 1986 treats the following as connected with a company:
- A director.
- A shadow director.
- An associate of a director or shadow director.
- An associate of the company.
Connection matters twice over. It extends the period the office-holder can examine, and it reverses the burden on the desire-to-prefer element.
How Is the Onset of Insolvency Identified?
The onset of insolvency is identified by reference to the date of the winding-up petition in a compulsory liquidation, the resolution for voluntary winding-up, or the date the company entered administration.
Because both periods count back from this date, an error of a few weeks can decide whether a payment is within reach at all.
What Must Be Shown When the Transaction Falls Within the Relevant Period?
Falling within the six-month or two-year window is only a threshold. The office-holder must still prove benefit and insolvency, and must deal with desire either by evidence or through the connected-person presumption.
How Can a Director or Creditor Prove or Rebut Desire to Prefer?
Desire is proved or rebutted by evidence of what actually influenced the decision-makers at the time, not by whether the payment looks reasonable in hindsight.
Where the recipient is connected, section 239(6) presumes the company was influenced by the required desire unless the recipient proves otherwise. For an unconnected creditor, the office-holder carries the burden of proving it.
What Evidence Shows Why the Company Made the Payment?
Records created at the time are usually far more persuasive than explanations written after the insolvency. Useful evidence includes:
- Board minutes recording the payment decision.
- Emails and messages between directors.
- Correspondence with the recipient.
- Cash-flow forecasts and management accounts.
- Bank statements and payment approvals.
- Witness evidence from the directors involved.
The pattern of payments also matters. A regular payment under an established trading arrangement tells a different story from an isolated payment made shortly before insolvency.
Can Commercial Pressure Explain Why a Creditor Was Paid?
Yes, it can. Commercial pressure may explain a payment where a creditor threatened to withdraw essential supplies or enforce security.
If the evidence shows the directors paid in order to keep trading rather than to improve that creditor’s position, the court may find the required desire was absent. The pressure must have been real, and the payment must have been a response to it. Correspondence should show the threat, why the supply or facility mattered to the business, and how the board reacted.
Does Professional Advice or a Belief That the Company Would Recover Decide the Claim?
Neither decides the claim on its own. A genuine belief that all creditors would be paid in full, or advice that a payment was proper, can form part of the evidence about the directors’ state of mind. Its weight depends on whether it is supported by what the directors knew and recorded at the time.
What Can an Office-Holder Recover Through a Preference Claim?
An office-holder can ask the court for an order restoring the position to what it would have been if the preference had not been given. Section 239(3) requires the court to make such order as it thinks fit for that purpose, and section 241 sets out the types of order available. The court has wide discretion to tailor the remedy to the facts.
Can the Court Order Repayment, Return of Property or Release of Security?
Yes. Typical orders include:
- Repayment of money received.
- Vesting property back in the company.
- Setting aside security granted for an existing debt.
The purpose is restoration, not punishment. The value returns to the insolvency estate for distribution, and the recipient may then prove as an ordinary creditor for the original debt.
How Does the Court Tailor a Remedy to the Insolvency Estate?
The court does not have to unwind a transaction in identical form. It looks at the value removed from the estate and makes an order that restores it, which may mean a money payment rather than the return of a specific asset.
What Protection May Apply to a Third Party Who Acquired Property?
A bona fide purchaser for value without notice of the relevant circumstances is protected. An order can affect someone other than the original recipient, but subject to that safeguard. Anyone who later bought the property or took a charge over it therefore needs careful analysis of their position.
What Is the Difference Between a Preference Claim and a Transaction at Undervalue?
A preference claim concerns creditor priority, while a transaction at undervalue concerns what the company received in return.
Section 238 targets transactions where the company receives no consideration, or significantly less value than it provides. Section 239 targets transactions that improve one creditor’s insolvency position and requires the company to have been influenced by a desire to produce that result. Both use the same six-month and two-year relevant periods, but the desire element is unique to preferences.
When Does a Transaction Prefer One Creditor Rather Than Transfer Value for Too Little?
Paying an existing debt in full may raise a preference question. The company receives full value through discharge of the debt, but one creditor jumps the queue.
Giving away an asset or selling it well below its worth raises an undervalue question. The company has lost value whether or not the buyer was ever a creditor.
Can the Same Transaction Be Challenged on More Than One Basis?
Yes. An office-holder may rely on both sections where a transaction meets both tests. This could happen where a director’s loan is repaid by transferring a company asset worth considerably more than the loan.
Who Can Bring a Preference Claim and What Records Should Be Preserved?
Only a liquidator or administrator can apply to court under section 239. The company itself cannot bring the claim, and nor can an individual creditor. The application is made to the High Court (Insolvency and Companies Court) or a County Court with insolvency jurisdiction, depending on the company’s circumstances and the value of the claim.
Preserving evidence early is essential. Once emails are deleted, accounting systems are closed or personal messages disappear, it becomes much harder to show why a payment was made.
What Should Directors, Recipients and Office-Holders Do First?
- Identify the payment, transfer or security under review and its date.
- Preserve bank statements, accounting records and payment approvals.
- Secure board minutes, emails, messages and creditor correspondence.
- Gather management accounts and cash-flow forecasts from the relevant period.
- Establish whether the recipient was connected with the company.
- Prepare a clear factual chronology before making any substantive admissions.
Which Documents Matter Most When Desire to Prefer Is Disputed?
The most useful documents record the decision when it was made. Office-holders will scrutinise the company’s books, bank statements and director loan accounts across the look-back period. Directors and recipients should also secure:
- Director notes and personal messages about the payment.
- Aged debtor and creditor reports.
- Director loan account statements.
- Records of any professional advice received.
Where a preference claim sits within a wider liquidation or administration, our insolvency and liquidation services team can review the office-holder’s investigation alongside the claim itself.
How Can Preference Claims Be Settled and What Limitation Risks Apply?
Many preference claims settle before trial, but a recipient should negotiate only after testing the office-holder’s evidence on each element.
Settlement may involve a reduced repayment, instalment terms or a charge over the recipient’s assets. Section 239 sets no minimum value for a claim, so even modest payments can be pursued. Whether a claim is commercially worthwhile depends on the evidence, the company’s financial position and the likely recovery for the estate. Office-holders often use third-party funding or contingency arrangements, so an estate with little cash may still pursue a claim.
How Should a Recipient Assess Repayment, Instalment and Security Proposals?
Before responding to any proposal, a recipient should understand:
- Which transaction is said to be a preference.
- Which relevant period is relied on and the onset date used.
- Whether the office-holder treats the recipient as connected.
- The insolvency evidence for the date of the transaction.
- The documents said to show a desire to prefer.
- Whether a proposed instalment or security arrangement is affordable and enforceable.
What Costs Risks Arise if a Preference Claim Is Defended or Settled Late?
The usual rule is that costs follow the event. A recipient who defends unsuccessfully may face an adverse costs order on top of repaying the preference, which in smaller claims can exceed the original sum.
An early, realistic assessment of the evidence is the best protection against that outcome. Avoid making admissions before the transaction and the available documents have been properly reviewed.
When Must a Preference Claim Be Started?
Under section 9 of the Limitation Act 1980, an action to recover a sum recoverable by virtue of an enactment cannot be brought more than six years after the cause of action accrued. When the cause of action accrued depends on the particular claim.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Repaying a Director’s Loan Automatically a Preference?
+−
No. The office-holder must show the repayment fell within the two-year period, left the director better off than in a liquidation, and was made while the company was insolvent or caused its insolvency. Because a director is connected, the director must then prove the company was not influenced by a desire to prefer them.
Can a Creditor Who Acted in Good Faith Be Required to Repay a Payment?
+−
Yes. Good faith is not a defence to a preference claim under section 239. If the statutory test is met, the court can order repayment even where the creditor knew nothing of the company’s insolvency. For an unconnected creditor, the focus is the company’s state of mind, although the creditor’s dealings with the company may shed light on it.
Can a Guarantor Be the Recipient of a Preference?
+−
Yes. Section 239 expressly covers sureties and guarantors. A director who has personally guaranteed a bank overdraft benefits if the company pays down that overdraft ahead of other creditors, even though the money goes to the bank. The office-holder may then pursue the director as the person preferred.
Is Security for New Lending Treated the Same as Security for an Existing Debt?
+−
Not necessarily. Security for a debt that was previously unsecured moves an existing creditor ahead of others, which is the classic preferential effect. Security given in exchange for genuinely new lending raises different questions, because the lender has put fresh money into the company rather than improving its position on an old debt.
What Happens if an Office-Holder Asks Me for Documents About a Payment?
+−
Take the request seriously and preserve everything, including emails, messages and accounting records. Avoid giving an informal explanation before reviewing the documents yourself. A considered response can help identify whether the claim has merit and whether an early commercial resolution is possible, before positions harden and costs build.
Get Expert Help With a Company Preference Claim Today
Delay rarely helps the recipient of a preference claim. Evidence of commercial pressure or the directors’ genuine reasoning can disappear quickly, and costs rise once proceedings are issued.
















