Key Takeaways
- The deadline to settle on HMRC’s 2020 disguised remuneration settlement terms was 30 September 2020. HMRC now operates a separate 2026 Loan Charge Settlement Scheme for eligible individuals and employers with unpaid Loan Charge liabilities.
- The Loan Charge covers disguised remuneration loans made between 9 December 2010 and 5 April 2019 that remained outstanding on 5 April 2019.
- A settlement offer under the 2026 scheme may reduce the liability by up to £70,.
- Recipients have at least 90 days to accept.
- If you do not settle, HMRC may pursue assessments, employer PAYE recovery, information notices, interest and penalties.
- A voluntary disclosure may reduce penalties, but you should check what action HMRC has already taken before making admissions or amending returns.
- HMRC may agree Time to Pay after reviewing your finances, although interest usually continues to accrue on unpaid tax.
- Go Legal is rated Excellent with over 300 five-star reviews and 5/5 on Trustpilot and Google, placing our solicitors among the best-reviewed litigation lawyers in England and Wales.
Can I Still Apply for an HMRC Loan Charge Settlement in 2026?
Possibly. The original deadline to settle on HMRC’s 2020 terms was 30 September 2020. However, eligible individuals and employers with unpaid Loan Charge liabilities may now receive an offer under HMRC’s Loan Charge Settlement Scheme. The scheme is established by The Employment and Trading Income etc. (Loan Charge Settlement Scheme) Regulations 2026.
HMRC’s current Loan Charge guidance identifies two routes for dealing with outstanding liabilities: the new Loan Charge Settlement Scheme and the disguised remuneration 2020 settlement terms.
How the 2026 Loan Charge Settlement Scheme works
Under the 2026 scheme, HMRC makes settlement offers to people liable to pay Loan Charge amounts. A person who accepts enters into a settlement agreement with HMRC. According to HMRC’s scheme guidance, an offer may include:
- A simplified calculation of the liability.
- A reduction for promoter fees.
- A further £5,000 deduction.
- An overall reduction capped at £70, 000.
- Payment by instalments for up to five years.
Recipients have at least 90 days to accept an offer. HMRC’s implementation guidance states that anyone who does not settle must pay the full Loan Charge liability and other applicable charges, such as late-payment interest.
Where the scheme does not apply, or the offer is wrong, other routes may include voluntary disclosure, Time to Pay or challenging an assessment. Our HMRC tax dispute solicitors can review an offer before you sign.
What Was the HMRC Loan Charge Settlement?
The 2020 settlement allowed taxpayers to resolve disguised remuneration liabilities by paying the relevant Income Tax and National Insurance. It covered certain outstanding loans made between 9 December 2010 and 5 April 2019. In many cases, HMRC offered reduced penalties and payment plans based on the taxpayer’s ability to pay.
Taxpayers who did not conclude a settlement were required to report and pay the Loan Charge, or agree a Time to Pay arrangement, by 30 September 2020. Those who missed that deadline and do not settle now face standard HMRC compliance action, including:
- Income Tax assessments and determinations.
- Discovery assessments.
- Employer PAYE and National Insurance recovery.
- Information notices.
- Interest and penalties.
Can earlier payments or review changes still affect the position?
Yes. Following the 2019 independent review, Finance Act 2020 removed loans made before 9 December 2010 from the Loan Charge.
The changes also took out certain loans made before 6 April 2016 where the taxpayer reasonably disclosed the scheme to HMRC and HMRC took no action, such as opening an enquiry. For a disclosure to count as reasonable, the information had to be enough for HMRC to identify:
- The loan.
- The person who received it.
- The nature of the arrangement.
- That an Income Tax liability arose in relation to the loan.
HMRC offered refunds of certain voluntary payments made before the review. This can apply where the payment related to loans made before 9 December 2010, or to loans covered by a reasonable disclosure where HMRC took no action. Taxpayers who settled before the changes were announced may be entitled to a refund or waiver of some or all of the amount paid on loans no longer in scope.
Does the Loan Charge Apply to My Disguised Remuneration Arrangement?
The Loan Charge applies to disguised remuneration loans made between 9 December 2010 and 5 April 2019 that remained outstanding on 5 April 2019. It brings the outstanding balance into income for 2018/19 or 2019/20, depending on the arrangement and the reporting position.
A taxpayer who agreed a contractual settlement, or repaid the loan by 5 April 2019 under the specified statutory arrangements, does not pay the Loan Charge. Instead, they pay the tax due for the earlier years.
Loans made before 9 December 2010 are outside the Loan Charge, but may still be subject to separate HMRC enquiries or assessments within normal time limits.
Calling a payment a “loan” does not settle its tax treatment. HMRC may examine whether the payment was really remuneration. The analysis may involve employment income, PAYE, National Insurance, agency arrangements, company distributions and anti-avoidance rules.
Common disguised remuneration structures
| Arrangement | How it may be relevant |
|---|---|
| Employee Benefit Trusts (EBTs) | An employer or intermediary may have provided funds to an employee through a trust. |
| Employer Financed Retirement Benefit Schemes (EFRBS) | Benefits or loans may have been routed through a retirement scheme. |
| Offshore trusts | An offshore trust may have made loans connected with employment or contracting income. |
| Contractor loan arrangements | A contractor may have received part of their earnings as a loan through an umbrella company or intermediary. |
Each structure is potentially caught if loans were outstanding on 5 April 2019. The position can also differ between the individual, the employer, an agency, an umbrella company and other intermediaries. HMRC can pursue PAYE and National Insurance from employers under Regulation 80 of the PAYE Regulations, or from employees personally in certain circumstances. You should confirm the correct party and the applicable time limits before accepting liability.
What Happens If I Missed the 2020 Settlement Deadline?
Missing the deadline does not remove the underlying liability. HMRC may continue with assessments, determinations, discovery assessments, information notices, penalties and employer PAYE recovery.
Start by establishing exactly what HMRC has done. A letter requesting information is different from a formal assessment, and each carries a different response, evidence requirement and appeal deadline.
Why HMRC’s wealthy-compliance activity matters in 2026
HMRC’s wealthy-compliance plan targets around 1.3 million people with income above £200,000 or assets above £2 million in any of the previous three years. HMRC created its Complex Cross-Tax and Offshore team in April 2025 to address complex wealthy and offshore non-compliance.
HMRC estimates the wealthy taxpayer tax gap for 2024/25 at £3.6 billion, equal to 6% of the total tax gap. Being in the target population does not make anyone liable. It does signal closer scrutiny of complex historic arrangements, offshore structures and incomplete disclosures.
Are HMRC assessments still within time?
That depends on the tax, the conduct and the statutory conditions. HMRC’s Compliance Handbook identifies these assessment periods, each running from the end of the relevant tax period:
- 4 years: the normal time limit.
- 6 years: where the loss of tax resulted from careless behaviour.
- 12 years: for specified offshore matters.
- 20 years: for deliberate behaviour or specified failures to comply.
The longer periods are not automatic. HMRC must meet the statutory conditions for the time limit it relies on. An old tax year is not automatically safe, but HMRC is not automatically entitled to assess it either.
Should I Make a Voluntary Disclosure to HMRC?
A voluntary disclosure may be appropriate where income, loans or tax liabilities were omitted or reported incorrectly. It does not remove the tax, interest or penalties. HMRC charges interest daily from the date the tax was due until payment. Penalties are a percentage of the additional tax and can reach 100% for UK liabilities and 200% for offshore liabilities.
The correct route depends on whether HMRC has already contacted you, opened an enquiry, issued an assessment or sent an information notice.
Which disclosure route applies?
Possible routes include:
- The Digital Disclosure Service.
- An amendment to a Self Assessment return.
- An employer PAYE correction.
- A specific HMRC disclosure facility.
Confirm the correct route before contacting HMRC. An inappropriate disclosure may create inconsistencies, admit disputed facts or weaken your ability to challenge an assessment.
Disclosing before HMRC contacts you may reduce penalties under HMRC’s penalty-reduction framework. The reduction depends on the quality, timing and completeness of the disclosure and on your cooperation. Voluntary disclosure alone does not guarantee a particular reduction.
If HMRC has already opened an enquiry or issued an assessment, a “voluntary” disclosure may not attract the same reduction. Challenging the assessment may then matter more than admitting the liability.
Can I Use Time to Pay for a Loan Charge Liability?
HMRC may agree a Time to Pay arrangement, but approval is discretionary. HMRC considers affordability, assets, income and expenditure before agreeing instalments, and will typically require a detailed statement of means covering:
- Employment or business income.
- Household and business expenditure.
- Property, savings, investments and pensions.
- Borrowing and other liabilities.
Address payment problems early, and make any proposal realistic and sustainable. HMRC may review the arrangement if your circumstances change. Interest usually continues to accrue while tax remains unpaid, and late-payment penalties may apply if the tax was not paid by the original due date.
The government’s proposed bank-deduction power is a separate matter. Following a consultation planned for summer 2027, it would target established debts of up to £5,000 for individuals and £10,000 for companies, only after standard collection activity and repeated failed engagement. It is a proposed debt-collection measure, not a Loan Charge settlement scheme.
How Can I Challenge an HMRC Assessment, Penalty or Information Notice?
You can challenge HMRC assessments, discovery assessments, penalties and information notices by appealing to the First-tier Tribunal (Tax) within 30 days of the decision, or by requesting an internal HMRC review first. The exact route depends on the decision being challenged.
Common grounds include:
- The assessment was issued outside the applicable time limit.
- HMRC had no grounds for a discovery assessment because the taxpayer made adequate disclosure.
- The amount is wrong, for example because it includes the wrong loans or tax years or ignores earlier payments.
- The penalty percentage is disproportionate to the conduct.
- The information notice is unduly onerous or seeks privileged material.
Failure to comply with an information notice can lead to penalties of up to £300 plus daily penalties, and HMRC may apply to the Tribunal for an order. An appeal against certain information-notice penalties must be made in writing to HMRC, state the grounds, and reach HMRC within 30 days beginning with the date the penalty assessment was issued.
The usual process is to:
- Identify the decision and the date it was issued.
- Protect the appeal deadline in writing.
- Review HMRC’s calculation and evidence.
- Gather loan, tax, disclosure and payment records.
- Consider an internal review.
- Prepare Tribunal proceedings if the dispute remains unresolved.
To learn more about this process, read our article on HMRC tax disputes and First-tier Tribunal appeals.
Separate 2026 proposals concerning loans from non-UK resident companies are intended to begin from April 2028 after a technical consultation in 2027. They concern company loans and should not be confused with historic disguised remuneration arrangements.
What Mistakes Should I Avoid in a Disguised Remuneration Dispute?
The most common mistake is assuming a label decides the tax. Even if a loan was described as “non-recourse” or “written off”, HMRC may argue that the write-off or release is itself taxable income or a benefit in kind.
Other traps include:
- Filing an amended Self Assessment return or making a disclosure before checking whether HMRC has opened an enquiry or issued an assessment. Doing so may admit facts you could otherwise challenge or lose penalty-reduction credit.
- Accepting a settlement offer without checking the loans, tax years and deductions it includes.
- Treating a Time to Pay application as acceptance that HMRC’s calculation is correct.
- Ignoring HMRC correspondence or information notices.
- Assuming bankruptcy, insolvency or company liquidation automatically extinguishes the liability.
Personal liabilities survive bankruptcy discharge in some cases, and HMRC may pursue directors or controlling persons under anti-avoidance rules. If insolvency is a realistic prospect, our insolvency and bankruptcy advice page explains the options.
If a tax adviser, accountant or scheme promoter recommended or implemented the arrangement, a separate claim may need consideration. Our solicitors have also written about professional negligence claims against tax advisers, which may help if you are considering whether poor advice caused your loss.
How Go Legal Can Help With HMRC Disguised Remuneration Disputes
Our HMRC tax disputes team advises individuals, contractors, directors and employers across England and Wales on Loan Charge liabilities and disguised remuneration disputes. Our work includes:
- Reviewing settlement offers under the 2026 Loan Charge Settlement Scheme.
- Assessing historic settlement payments and potential refunds.
- Advising on and preparing voluntary disclosures.
- Preparing Time to Pay applications.
- Reviewing assessments, discovery assessments, penalties and information notices for time limits, procedural defects and quantum.
- Representing clients in HMRC meetings, alternative dispute resolution and mediation.
- Appealing to the First-tier Tribunal (Tax).
We review the loan documentation, tax returns, payment records and HMRC correspondence before recommending settlement, disclosure, payment or challenge. Every new matter starts with a free initial consultation to assess your position and options.
Frequently Asked Questions
Do I still qualify for an HMRC Loan Charge settlement in 2026?
+−
Possibly. The 30 September 2020 deadline has passed, but the 2026 Loan Charge Settlement Scheme applies to eligible individuals and employers with unpaid Loan Charge liabilities. An offer may include a simplified calculation, specified deductions and a reduction of up to £70,000. If the scheme does not fit, voluntary disclosure, Time to Pay or a challenge may be available.
What happens if I missed the 2020 settlement deadline?
+−
You may still face assessments, discovery assessments, information notices, employer PAYE recovery and penalties. HMRC’s Complex Cross-Tax and Offshore team, created in April 2025, focuses on complex wealthy and offshore cases. Identify exactly what HMRC has issued before deciding whether to settle, disclose, negotiate payment or appeal, because each route carries different deadlines.
Does the Loan Charge apply to my particular loan or remuneration arrangement?
+−
It may, if the loan was made between 9 December 2010 and 5 April 2019 and was outstanding on 5 April 2019. Earlier loans fall outside the Loan Charge but may still be assessed within normal time limits. The answer turns on the loan documents, how payments were structured and what HMRC was told at the time.
Should I make a voluntary disclosure to HMRC, and will it reduce penalties?
+−
It may. Disclosing before HMRC contacts you can reduce penalties, depending on the quality, timing and completeness of the disclosure and your cooperation. If HMRC has already opened an enquiry or issued an assessment, the reduction may be smaller, and an early admission could weaken a challenge you would otherwise win.
Can I use Time to Pay, and what information will HMRC require?
+−
HMRC may agree instalments after reviewing a detailed statement of your income, expenditure, assets, including property, savings, investments and pensions, and liabilities. Approval is discretionary, interest usually continues until the tax is paid, and late-payment penalties may still apply. Raising payment problems early gives you the widest range of options.
Speak to a Loan Charge Settlement Scheme Solicitor Today
The 2020 deadline has passed, but a settlement offer under the 2026 scheme, a voluntary disclosure, Time to Pay or a challenge to HMRC may still be open to you. Acting late can cost you the offer acceptance window, an appeal deadline or penalty-reduction credit, and interest continues to run on unpaid tax.
















