Key Takeaways
- Disguised remuneration is pay for work routed through a third party as a loan, advance or grant instead of salary, avoiding PAYE Income Tax and National Insurance contributions.
- The HMRC loan charge can apply where loans made between 9 December 2010 and 5 April 2019 remained outstanding on 5 April 2 019.
- Check payslips, P60s, bank statements and agreements for a small salary alongside loans, advances, grants or payments from offshore trusts.
- Do not ignore HMRC correspondence. Formal assessments usually require an appeal within 30 days, and inaction can lead to interest, penalties and enforcement.
- Gather your records and take advice before responding to HMRC, admitting liability, repaying a loan or accepting a settlement.
- Your main options are to settle, challenge the calculation, argue an exclusion, request Time to Pay or consider insolvency if payment is unaffordable.
- Go Legal is rated Excellent with over 300 five-star reviews and 5/5 on Trustpilot and Google, placing our solicitors among the best-reviewed litigation lawyers in England and Wales.
Disguised Remuneration and the Loan Charge: Are You Affected?
Were you paid a small salary alongside a loan, grant or advance through an umbrella company or offshore trust? HMRC may treat that payment as employment income subject to PAYE Income Tax and National Insurance, even if you were told the arrangement was compliant or non-repayable.
Many contractors were misled, or had little choice about how they were paid. That does not remove the tax risk, but it does affect how you should respond. Historic loans outstanding on 5 April 2019 are the main concern, and what you say or pay now can shape the outcome.
Our London-based solicitors can review your documents and explain whether settlement, a challenge, Time to Pay, insolvency advice or a response to a separate loan repayment demand is appropriate. Call 0207 459 4037 or book a free consultation.
What Is Disguised Remuneration and How Does a Contractor Loan Scheme Work?
Disguised remuneration is an arrangement where employment income is paid through a third party, often an umbrella company, trust or intermediary, as a purported loan, grant, advance or other non-salary payment. HMRC treats money received in return for work or services as taxable employment income, subject to PAYE Income Tax and National Insurance contributions.
These arrangements commonly involved contractors, agency workers, consultants, company directors and some public-sector workers. Healthcare, IT and construction workers were frequently offered umbrella company arrangements of this kind.
The typical promise was simple: a small taxed salary, plus a much larger sum from an offshore trust, such as Felicitas or ML Trustees, that was tax-free and would never need to be repaid.
HMRC describes these arrangements as tax avoidance in which earnings were presented as loans instead of salary or wages. They are not compliant tax planning. HMRC does not approve marketed tax-avoidance schemes, and a promoter calling an arrangement “approved”, “compliant” or “legal” does not determine the tax result.
Many people joined because an agency required a particular umbrella company, or because the arrangement was sold as compliant and beneficial. A higher take-home figure looked attractive, particularly to contractors with little bargaining power.
How Did Umbrella Company Loan Schemes Pay Contractors?
An umbrella company loan scheme split a contractor’s pay into a small PAYE salary and a much larger payment described as a loan, grant or advance.
How Did the Small Salary and Larger Loan Payment Structure Work?
The payment chain often looked like this:
- The contractor provided services to an end client.
- An agency paid an umbrella company or intermediary for that work.
- The umbrella company paid a small salary through PAYE, often at or just above minimum wage, and deducted tax and National Insurance on that element only.
- A separate third party, often an offshore employee benefit trust, paid the balance as a purported loan, advance or grant.
Some schemes used partnerships or other intermediaries instead. Structures varied, but the central question is always whether the payment was really made in return for work.
The result was significantly higher net pay than ordinary PAYE would produce, alongside an undeclared tax liability that built up year after year.
Why Were Contractor Loans Described as Non-Repayable?
Calling a payment a loan made it look different from salary. In practice, the “loan” was structured so that repayment was unlikely ever to be required.
HMRC warns in its Spotlight 39 guidance on re-describing loans that changing a payment’s description does not change its character. The loan charge can reach credit and rights to payment, whatever they are called.
Could the HMRC Loan Charge Apply to an Outstanding Disguised Remuneration Loan?
The loan charge may apply where a disguised remuneration loan meets specific statutory conditions on dates, repayment and settlement. It is not a blanket charge on every historic payment described as a loan.
The charge is contained in Schedule 11 to the Finance (No. 2) Act 2017, which works alongside Part 7A of the Income Tax (Earnings and Pensions) Act 2003 through the disguised remuneration provisions of that Act. It applies to loans and quasi-loans outstanding on 5 April 2019. “Loan” includes any form of credit and any payment purported to be made by way of a loan, so relabelling a payment as an “advance” does not take it outside the regime.
Which Conditions Must Be Checked Before Assuming the Loan Charge Applies?
| Condition | Employees | Self-employed |
|---|---|---|
| Loan made on or after | 9 December 2010 | 9 December 2010 |
| Loan received before | 6 April 2019 | 6 April 2017 |
| Provided by | A third party | A third party |
| Not repaid in full by | 5 April 2019 | 5 April 2019 |
| Tax not settled with HMRC by | 30 September 2020 | 30 September 2020 |
A review should also establish whether the payment related to employment income or trading profits, and whether the income was already fully taxed.
Where the conditions are met, the outstanding loan is treated as employment income arising in the 2018/19 tax year and taxed at your marginal rate, with potential PAYE and National Insurance consequences. Bunching several years of loans into one tax year can create a substantial liability.
The original deadline for many taxpayers to report and pay through Self Assessment, or to contact HMRC to agree payment arrangements, was 30 September 2020.
What Changed After the Independent Review of the Loan Charge?
The Independent Loan Charge Review, led by Sir Amyas Morse, narrowed the charge but did not abolish it. On 5 December 2019, the Government announced changes excluding loans made before 9 December 2010.
The government guidance following the review sets out those changes. In 2026, the charge remains in force for in-scope loans, and HMRC continues to pursue outstanding cases, issue assessments and agree settlements.
The loan charge also sits alongside HMRC’s other powers. HMRC can investigate earlier years, assess PAYE and National Insurance, and impose interest or penalties on employers, scheme users or trustees.
How Can I Tell If I Was in a Disguised Remuneration Scheme?
You may have been in a disguised remuneration scheme if your taxable salary was much lower than the total you actually received for your work.
What Are the Warning Signs?
- Payslips showing a “loan”, “advance”, “grant” or similar non-salary payment, often from an offshore trust.
- Unusually high net pay compared with your gross salary.
- A P60 showing low taxable pay while your bank account received significantly more.
- An umbrella company engagement during the 2000s to 2010s, particularly where an offshore trust was involved.
- Being told the arrangement was “HMRC-compliant”, “approved” or “legal tax planning”.
- An HMRC nudge letter or enquiry letter mentioning disguised remuneration, the loan charge or a specific scheme or trust name.
What Documents Should I Check?
Collect payslips, P60s, Self Assessment returns, bank statements, agency agreements, umbrella company contracts, loan agreements, trust deeds, repayment correspondence and every HMRC letter. Keep original electronic files where possible, because payment references, email headers and document dates help establish the route and purpose of each payment.
What Does an HMRC Letter Mean?
A nudge letter is an informal prompt asking whether you were involved in a disguised remuneration scheme. It is not a formal assessment, but it shows that HMRC is aware of your potential involvement.
A formal enquiry into your Self Assessment return, or a discovery assessment, is different, and statutory deadlines apply. Check the tax years under review, the scheme or trust named, the information requested, any enclosed calculation and the response or appeal deadline.
What Should I Do If HMRC and a Loan Repayment Claimant Contact Me at the Same Time?
Treat them as two separate legal problems. HMRC’s tax claim and a third party’s demand to repay an alleged loan are different issues, even though both arise from the same arrangement.
How Does the Two-Track Review Separate Tax Liability From an Alleged Loan Debt?
The first track concerns HMRC: whether payments were taxable, whether the loan charge applies, any enquiry or assessment, settlement and affordability. HMRC may pursue employers for PAYE and employer National Insurance, scheme users for Income Tax and employee National Insurance, or both, depending on the arrangement and the statutory rules.
The second track concerns the alleged loan debt. Some scheme users are receiving demands to repay the original “loan” from trustees or assignees, such as West 28th Street. These demands may be unenforceable or statute-barred. Issues include limitation, whether the “loan” was a genuine loan and whether the demand complies with consumer credit or FCA rules.
The FCA has warned that some contractors, consultants and agency workers have received legal letters demanding repayment and threatening court action. It advises anyone unsure whether they are liable to consider carefully before paying and to consider legal advice.
What Should I Do Before Replying, Paying or Admitting Liability?
- Preserve every letter, email, agreement, payslip and bank record.
- Identify who has contacted you: HMRC, a trustee, an assignee, a solicitor or a debt collector.
- Note every response date, payment request and appeal instruction.
- Check whether HMRC has already assessed your position through settlement agreements, PAYE determinations, Self Assessment notices, employer records or payment history.
- Avoid admissions, acknowledgments of debt, settlement offers or repayments until the position has been reviewed. Anything you say can be used to assess your liability.
The most common mistakes are ignoring HMRC letters while deadlines run, assuming the scheme was compliant because a promoter said so, and repaying the “loan” without advice. Repayment does not automatically resolve the tax position, because its timing, source of funds and terms can affect the treatment.
What Are My Options if HMRC Says I Owe Tax on Disguised Remuneration?
There are five main routes: settle, challenge the liability or calculation, rely on an exclusion, ask for Time to Pay or take insolvency advice. The right one depends on your scheme documents, dates, HMRC’s position, affordability and whether you have defences.
Can I Settle an HMRC Disguised Remuneration Liability?
Yes. Individuals and employers with an unpaid loan-charge liability may use HMRC’s loan charge settlement scheme or the disguised remuneration 2020 settlement terms. Settlement can bring reduced penalties and manageable payment plans, and HMRC has arrangements for affordable settlements.
Before discussions start, assemble your payment and loan records, tax returns, previous HMRC correspondence, details of any earlier settlement and a clear picture of your income, expenditure, assets and liabilities.
Can I Challenge an HMRC Loan Charge Calculation or Assessment?
Yes, if you have grounds. A challenge may argue that:
- The arrangement does not meet the statutory conditions.
- The loan was repaid before 5 April 2
019. - An exclusion applies, such as a loan made before 9 December 2010.
- The income was already taxed or settled.
- The wrong taxpayer has been identified.
- HMRC’s figures are wrong.
- Time limits or other procedural requirements were not met.
Appeals are made to the First-tier Tribunal (Tax). Appeals against formal assessments usually have to be made within 30 days, although the notice will state the applicable deadline. Our HMRC tax disputes solicitors can identify which document you hold and which route is available.
Can I Ask HMRC for Time to Pay?
HMRC may agree a Time to Pay arrangement if you cannot pay in full immediately. You will need affordability evidence covering income, essential expenditure, assets and liabilities. Any proposal should be based on a checked calculation, not HMRC’s first figure.
When Should I Consider Insolvency Advice?
Insolvency advice becomes relevant where the liability remains unaffordable even with a payment plan, and settlement is not viable. Options may include bankruptcy or an IVA for individuals and liquidation for companies. Directors need advice on personal liability, trustee claims and how tax debt is treated in insolvency before taking any formal step. You may find our guide on insolvency and bankruptcy advice useful.
How Go Legal Helps With Disguised Remuneration and HMRC Loan Charge Disputes
Go Legal is a London-based commercial litigation law firm acting for individuals, directors, professionals and businesses across England and Wales.
We begin with the documents. We review the payment structure, historic correspondence and records to establish whether you were in a disguised remuneration scheme, whether the loan charge is likely to apply and what your realistic options are. We also separate HMRC’s tax position from any alleged loan repayment claim.
Our work includes:
- Handling HMRC correspondence so you do not inadvertently admit liability or miss a deadline.
- Reviewing HMRC’s figures, identifying errors and arguing exclusions or that the statutory conditions are not met.
- Engaging with HMRC’s settlement team to agree manageable terms and seek to reduce penalties and interest.
- Representing you in the First-tier Tribunal (Tax).
- Assessing enforceability, limitation and validity in demands from West 28th Street and other trustees or assignees, and defending or settling them as appropriate.
- Advising on bankruptcy, IVAs, liquidation and director liability where the debt is unaffordable, working with insolvency practitioners.
- Investigating professional negligence claims against advisers who recommended the scheme.
Frequently Asked Questions
What Is Disguised Remuneration?
+−
Disguised remuneration is employment income paid through a third party, often as a loan, grant or advance from an offshore trust, instead of salary, to avoid PAYE Income Tax and National Insurance contributions. HMRC’s position is that all money paid in return for your services should be taxed through PAYE, and that these arrangements are not compliant with tax law.
Am I Still at Risk of the Loan Charge in 2026?
+−
Yes. The loan charge remains in force for in-scope loans made between 9 December 2010 and 5 April 2019 that were outstanding on 5 April 2019. HMRC continues to issue assessments and agree settlements. If you have not settled or been assessed, you may still receive an enquiry letter or assessment, and a trustee or assignee may separately pursue the alleged loan.
I Was Told the Scheme Was HMRC-Compliant. Am I Still Liable?
+−
Yes. HMRC does not approve marketed tax-avoidance schemes, and a promoter’s claim that an arrangement was approved, compliant or legal tax planning does not determine the tax result. You may have a professional negligence claim against the promoter or adviser who misled you, but that claim does not remove your tax liability to HMRC.
Can I Just Ignore HMRC’s Letters?
+−
No. Ignoring HMRC does not make the liability go away, and statutory deadlines continue to run. If you do not appeal a formal assessment or discovery notice in time (usually 30 days), you risk losing the right to challenge it. Inaction can also bring higher penalties, interest and enforcement, including county court judgments, charging orders and bankruptcy petitions.
What If I Cannot Afford to Pay?
+−
HMRC may agree a Time to Pay arrangement if you can show you cannot pay in full immediately, supported by evidence of income, expenses, assets and liabilities. If the liability is unaffordable even with a payment plan, insolvency options may need to be considered, which requires specialist advice on director liability, trustee claims and how tax debt is treated.
What Should I Do About a West 28th Street Repayment Demand?
+−
Do not pay or admit liability without advice. A demand from West 28th Street or another assignee is separate from HMRC’s tax claim, and its enforceability is disputed. It may be statute-barred, the “loan” may not have been genuine, or the demand may not comply with consumer credit or FCA rules. Preserve every document and act promptly.
Get Expert Help With Disguised Remuneration and the Loan Charge
Disguised remuneration schemes can leave contractors facing substantial tax claims years after payments were described as loans, advances or grants. Delay narrows your options: appeal deadlines pass, penalties and interest grow, and enforcement can follow even where you were misled about compliance.
Our solicitors advise contractors, directors and professionals across England and Wales on HMRC enquiries, loan charge assessments, settlement, payment arrangements, tribunal challenges and demands from trustees or assignees. We review your documents, assess your position and help you choose a proportionate response.
















