Key Takeaways
- Commercial mediation is a confidential negotiation led by a neutral mediator, who cannot decide the dispute or impose an outcome.
- Mediation suits disputes where a commercial relationship, confidentiality or speed matters more than a binding public ruling.
- Prepare a concise position statement, core documents and realistic settlement limits, and make sure a decision-maker with authority attends.
- On the day, the mediator usually works through private meetings and shuttle diplomacy. Your solicitor advises on offers and records the agreed terms.
- Following Churchill v Merthyr Tydfil County Borough Council, courts may order parties to take part in ADR, and unreasonably refusing mediation can lead to costs penalties.
- A signed settlement agreement binds the parties. If mediation fails, litigation can continue and the discussions generally remain without prejudice.
- Karim Oualnan can act as an accredited neutral mediator, or our solicitors can prepare you for mediation and represent you on the day.
- Go Legal is rated Excellent with over 300 five-star reviews and 5/5 on Trustpilot and Google, placing our solicitors among the best-reviewed litigation lawyers in England and Wales.
What Is Commercial Mediation and How Does It Work in England and Wales?
Commercial mediation is a structured, confidential negotiation in which an independent, neutral mediator helps businesses reach their own settlement.
The mediator does not decide who is right. They cannot impose a payment, order disclosure or force either party to accept an offer. Their role is to identify the real obstacles to settlement, test each side’s position and help the parties explore workable options.
The government describes civil mediation as a flexible and confidential process in which an independent and impartial mediator helps people, businesses or organisations discuss the issues, negotiate and seek a mutually agreeable solution. The mediator may speak to the parties separately and, if they agree, bring them together.
Commercial mediation commonly resolves disputes involving:
- Breach of contract
- Debt recovery
- Shareholder, partnership and director disputes
- Intellectual property and trading disputes
- Construction disputes
- Professional negligence claims
- Insolvency-related claims
The key features of mediation are:
- Usually voluntary: the parties agree to mediate, although a court can order participation, and either party can walk away before a settlement is signed.
- Confidential: the process is private, unlike a public court hearing.
- Without prejudice: offers and concessions made in mediation generally cannot be referred to in court if it fails.
- Facilitative, not adjudicative: the mediator has no power to impose an outcome.
- Flexible: the parties control timing, venue, format and the choice of mediator, before or during proceedings, in person or online.
A neutral mediator cannot advise either side on the strength of its case or whether to accept an offer. A solicitor representing one party can advise on evidence, litigation risk, settlement proposals and the wording of any agreement. Knowing which role you need is the first decision to make.
Our solicitors can represent you at mediation in a commercial dispute. Alternatively, where both sides agree and conflict checks permit, Karim Oualnan can act as the neutral mediator. The two roles never overlap in the same matter.
When Should a Business Use Mediation Instead of Arbitration or Litigation?
Mediation is often the commercially sensible choice where a business needs a practical solution rather than a winner and a loser.
The difference in time and cost is significant. Litigation can take 18 to 36 months to reach trial and cost £50,000 to £500,000 or more, while a commercial mediation usually takes a single day plus preparation. Commercial mediation typically results in settlement in 70 to 80% of cases.
Mediation works particularly well where:
- You want to preserve a supplier, customer, joint venture or shareholder relationship
- The dispute turns on facts rather than a pure point of law
- Confidentiality matters, for example trade secrets or reputation
- The cost and risk of litigation outweigh the value of the dispute
It is less suitable where a party needs an urgent injunction or freezing order, a binding precedent on a novel legal point, or public vindication. It can also struggle where one side is using the process to delay, or where fraud is alleged and disclosure is needed before settlement is realistic.
| Commercial consideration | Mediation | Arbitration | Court litigation |
|---|---|---|---|
| Who controls the outcome? | The parties negotiate their own settlement. | An arbitrator decides the dispute. | A judge decides the dispute. |
| Is a decision imposed? | No. Settlement depends on agreement. | Yes, through an arbitral award. | Yes, through a court judgment. |
| Is it private? | Yes, it is a confidential process. | Generally, yes. | Hearings are generally public. |
| Typical timescale | One day plus preparation | 6 to 18 months | 12 to 36 months to trial |
| Can it support an ongoing relationship? | Often, because the parties design practical solutions. | Sometimes, but the process is adversarial. | Less often, because proceedings are adversarial. |
| Can it include non-financial terms? | Yes, including revised contracts, releases and future trading terms. | Only within the issues submitted for decision. | The court’s remedies are limited by the legal claim. |
Mediation can take place before a claim is issued, during proceedings (often around the case management conference or shortly before trial) or even after judgment, for example in enforcement or costs disputes.
Many commercial contracts contain a dispute-resolution clause requiring mediation before arbitration or court proceedings. Ignoring it may be a breach of contract, and the court may stay proceedings until the parties have mediated. Review the clause as soon as a dispute arises.
Can a Court Require Parties to Mediate or Take Part in ADR?
A court can require parties to take part in a proportionate non-court dispute-resolution process, but it cannot compel them to agree a settlement.
The leading authority is James Churchill v Merthyr Tydfil County Borough Council [2023] EWCA Civ 1416. Mr Churchill brought a nuisance claim over Japanese knotweed on or connected with land owned by the Council, which adjoined his property. The case reached the Court of Appeal from the County Court at Merthyr Tydfil, with the Law Society and Bar Council intervening. The court described the “headline questions” as:
whether “a court can lawfully order the parties to court proceedings to engage in a non-court-based dispute resolution process, and, if so, in what circumstances it should do so.”
The Court of Appeal held that a court may lawfully order parties to participate in a non-court-based process, provided the order does not impair the essence of a party’s right to a judicial hearing and is proportionate to the legitimate aim of resolving disputes fairly, quickly and at reasonable cost.
The court looked closely at the process in issue. It was non-binding, did not prejudice the right to sue, did not cause substantial delay, suspended limitation, involved no fees and offered non-electronic means of participation. The court did not hold that every mediation or ADR process can automatically be imposed. The legality and proportionality of the particular process remain relevant, and the decision has since been reflected in changes to the Civil Procedure Rules.
Court-connected mediation is also now built into small claims. Under Practice Direction 51ZE, Small Claims Track Automatic Referral to Mediation Pilot Scheme, the pilot applies to claims issued on or after 22 May 2024 and runs until 6 April 2027. Qualifying small-claims money disputes are referred automatically to the HMCTS Small Claims Mediation Service.
The government has confirmed that parties in money claims up to £10,000 must take part in a free one-hour mediation appointment provided by that service. HMCTS has reported that the scheme was extended to new claims submitted through the Online Civil Money Claims service from 5 November 2024. Scope depends on the claim type and issuing route, so do not assume every business claim under £10,000 is covered.
Refusal carries real risk. Under the court’s general costs discretion in CPR 44.2, a party that unreasonably refuses mediation or fails to engage constructively may be penalised in costs, even if it wins at trial. In assessing reasonableness, courts have applied principles from Halsey v Milton Keynes General NHS Trust, including the nature of the dispute, the merits, whether mediation had a reasonable prospect of success and the costs of mediation.
How Does the Commercial Mediation Process Work Step by Step?
Commercial mediation usually begins with a court order, a contractual clause or a voluntary proposal, followed by preparation and a single mediation day.
How Is Mediation Started and How Is a Mediator Chosen?
The parties usually choose the mediator jointly, from the Civil Mediation Council register, a CEDR panel, the Chartered Institute of Arbitrators directory or personal recommendation. If they cannot agree, a mediation provider can appoint one.
There is no single statutory professional title that every mediator must hold, so check:
- Independence from both parties
- Sector experience, such as construction, intellectual property, tax or insolvency
- Accreditation, insurance and membership of recognised bodies
- Availability and cost
The parties then sign a mediation agreement covering the date, venue or online platform, the mediator’s fee and how it is shared (often equally, though the parties can agree otherwise), confidentiality, who attends with authority to settle, and costs. Each party usually bears its own legal costs unless the settlement provides otherwise.
What Happens Before the Mediation Day?
- Position statement: a concise case summary, typically 3 to 10 pages, covering the facts, key issues, strengths, weaknesses and settlement position. It is commonly sent to the mediator and the other side around 7 days before.
- Bundle of key documents: core contracts, correspondence, invoices and expert reports, not a full trial bundle.
- Mediator pre-calls: short private calls, often 15 to 30 minutes per party, where the mediator explores the issues and gauges settlement appetite. Use the call to flag your key concerns and gauge whether the mediator’s style is facilitative or evaluative.
What Happens on the Mediation Day?
Each party starts in its own room. The decision-maker attends with their solicitor or barrister, and an expert if needed.
The mediator may hold an optional opening joint session, where each side makes a short statement, typically 5 to 10 minutes and usually delivered by the lawyer. A joint session can humanise the dispute, but where feelings run high many mediators move straight to private meetings.
In these private meetings, known as caucuses, the mediator reality-tests each side. Expect questions such as: what is your best and worst case at trial, what are your costs to trial, and what do you really need to settle today? The mediator carries authorised offers between rooms, known as shuttle diplomacy, and keeps your confidential information private unless you permit disclosure.
Either party can take a break to consult its solicitor, seek instructions or reconsider. If agreement is reached, the key terms are written down and signed before anyone leaves. Online mediation follows the same structure using breakout rooms, but needs secure document access, a private space and reliable technology.
How Should a Business Prepare Its Settlement Strategy and Authority?
Prepare by comparing any settlement with your realistic alternative if no agreement is reached, often called your BATNA (best alternative to a negotiated agreement).
That assessment covers the likely outcome at trial, evidential weaknesses, management time, the risk of paying the other side’s costs and whether any judgment could actually be recovered. Costs to trial typically run at £50,000 to £150,000 in the County Court and £100,000 to £500,000 or more on the High Court multi-track. Your walk-away point should reflect that realistic alternative, not your best-case outcome.
Agree an opening position, target settlement and walk-away point before the day. The person attending must have authority covering both money and non-financial terms. For a company, a board resolution or written authority may be needed, because a representative who must “check with head office” can lose a deal just as it becomes achievable.
Non-financial terms worth considering include:
- Confidentiality provisions and mutual releases
- Future supply arrangements
- Intellectual property ownership or licences
- Public statements or withdrawal of allegations
- Share transfers or resignations
For shareholder, director or partnership disputes, you may find our guide on Director and Shareholder Disputes useful. Our solicitors can help you set settlement parameters before mediation; call 0207 459 4037 to discuss your position.
What Does Commercial Mediation Cost and Who Pays for It?
Commercial mediation typically costs £5,000 to £10,000 per party for a half day and £8,000 to £20,000 per party for a full day, depending on the seniority of the mediator and legal team.
The main components are:
- Mediator’s fee: £1,500 to £5,000 or more per day, depending on seniority, claim value and complexity
- Venue hire: £500 to £1,500 for London meeting rooms, or nothing if the mediation is online
- Legal costs: solicitor and barrister fees for preparation and attendance
- Expert fees: where an expert attends
Each party usually bears its own legal costs unless the settlement says otherwise, so costs are a negotiable term in their own right. For qualifying small claims, the HMCTS appointment described above is free.
How Are Confidentiality and Mediation Settlements Protected?
Mediation discussions are protected by the without-prejudice rule and the confidentiality terms of the mediation agreement, while settlements are protected by careful drafting.
Is Commercial Mediation Confidential and Without Prejudice?
Mediation discussions are generally conducted on a without-prejudice basis, meaning offers and concessions cannot normally be referred to in court if mediation fails. That protection is not absolute and depends on the circumstances and the documents signed.
Confidentiality is a separate concept governing who may disclose information, and legal professional privilege is different again. Mediation agreements commonly allow exceptions, for example where criminal conduct or a child safeguarding concern is disclosed, or where a court orders disclosure.
Settlement terms are not automatically confidential. If confidentiality matters, write it into the settlement agreement, so that any breach is a breach of contract giving rise to a claim for damages or an injunction.
Is a Mediation Settlement Legally Binding?
Once the parties sign a written settlement agreement, it is a binding contract enforceable in court. If one party fails to pay, the other can sue for breach of the settlement rather than reopening the original dispute.
Where proceedings are already under way, the settlement can be recorded in a Tomlin order: a consent order staying the proceedings, with the terms in a confidential schedule. If a party breaches those terms, the other party can apply to the court to enforce them without issuing a new claim.
Before signing, check the agreement covers:
- The correct legal parties
- Payment amounts, dates and interest for late payment
- Costs
- Mutual releases of claims
- Confidentiality and ongoing obligations
- Tax treatment where relevant
- Dispute resolution for breach, governing law and jurisdiction
What Happens If Commercial Mediation Does Not Settle the Dispute?
If mediation does not settle the dispute, the parties return to court proceedings, or issue a claim if the mediation was pre-action.
Neither party is obliged to settle, even if the mediator recommends terms. An unsuccessful mediation still has value. It can narrow the issues, reveal missing evidence and show which terms matter most to the other side. Use that insight, within the limits of without-prejudice protection, to refine your litigation strategy.
Many parties mediate again later, after expert reports or as trial approaches, when costs and risk feel more immediate. Keep complying with court directions throughout, because negotiations do not pause your procedural obligations.
Our solicitors can run mediation alongside litigation preparation, including in professional negligence and insolvency disputes.
Frequently Asked Questions
What Is the Difference Between Mediation and Arbitration?
+−
Mediation is a facilitated negotiation: the parties decide whether to settle, and the mediator has no power to impose a decision. Arbitration is a private adjudication in which an arbitrator hears evidence and makes a binding award enforceable like a court judgment. Mediation becomes binding only once the parties sign a settlement agreement.
Do I Need a Solicitor at Commercial Mediation?
+−
You are not legally required to have one, but representation is strongly recommended in commercial disputes. A solicitor experienced in mediation prepares your position statement, presents your opening, advises on offers during private caucuses, reality-tests your position and ensures the signed agreement reflects the deal actually reached, including the non-financial terms.
Can the Mediator Give Me Legal Advice?
+−
No. The mediator is neutral and cannot advise either party on the merits of its case or whether to accept an offer. They can ask difficult questions and test assumptions, but the decision to settle is yours. Independent legal advice on risk, costs and drafting must come from your own solicitor.
Can Mediation Take Place Before Court Proceedings Are Issued?
+−
Yes. Pre-action mediation is common and can resolve a dispute before litigation costs build up. A proposal to mediate often features in pre-action correspondence. Check your limitation position first, because negotiations do not stop time running against a claim.
What Authority Should a Director Have at Mediation?
+−
A director should have clear authority to make and accept offers up to an agreed limit, and to agree non-financial terms such as releases, confidentiality, future supply or intellectual property rights. Without it, the other side may doubt your seriousness, and a workable deal can collapse while approval is sought.
Get Expert Help With Commercial Mediation
Delay narrows your options. A missed contractual mediation step, an unanswered ADR proposal or an expired limitation period can cost you leverage, costs protection or the claim itself.
Go Legal is a London-based commercial litigation firm acting for individuals, directors, professionals and businesses across England and Wales. Karim Oualnan can act as an accredited neutral mediator where both parties agree. Alternatively, our solicitors can represent you, helping you to:
- Decide whether mediation can resolve the real commercial problem
- Prepare a focused position statement and bundle
- Set settlement parameters and confirm authority
- Weigh offers during private caucuses
- Draft or review the settlement terms
- Continue straight into litigation if settlement is not reached
Go Legal is rated Excellent with over 300 five-star reviews and a 5 out of 5 rating on Trustpilot and Google. To discuss whether mediation is right for your dispute, book a free consultation or call us on 0207 459 4037.
















