Key Takeaways
- An HMRC statutory demand gives you 21 days from service to pay the tax debt or reach an agreement to pay.
- Do not ignore the demand. HMRC may present a winding-up petition against a company or a bankruptcy petition against an individual.
- An individual who wants to challenge the demand must apply to the court to set it aside within 18 days of service. This is the legal deadline, not a safety margin.
- A company cannot use the individual set-aside procedure. Where the debt is genuinely disputed, it may need to apply urgently to restrain HMRC from presenting a winding-up petition.
- Grounds to challenge include a genuine and substantial dispute, payment, a defective demand or defective service, a counterclaim or set-off.
- If the debt is undisputed but unaffordable, seek a written Time to Pay agreement from HMRC. Negotiations alone do not stop the clock.
- Go Legal is rated Excellent with over 300 five-star reviews and 5/5 on Trustpilot and Google, placing our solicitors among the best-reviewed litigation lawyers in England and Wales.
What Is an HMRC Statutory Demand?
An HMRC statutory demand is a formal written demand under the Insolvency Act 1986 requiring you to pay a tax debt. If it is not paid, agreed or set aside, HMRC can use it as evidence that you cannot pay your debts. HMRC uses statutory demands for arrears of VAT, PAYE and National Insurance contributions, Corporation Tax, Self Assessment, penalties and Accelerated Payment Notices.
According to official GOV.UK guidance, you have 21 days after receiving a statutory demand to pay or reach an agreement to pay. If you do not respond, the creditor can apply to bankrupt an individual or wind up a company. A creditor can make a statutory demand without a lawyer, and the guidance states that a debt over six years old cannot usually be pursued in this way.
You have three realistic options:
- Pay the debt in full.
- Challenge the demand, where genuine legal grounds exist.
- Negotiate a written Time to Pay arrangement with HMRC.
The route to a court challenge depends on whether the demand is addressed to a company or an individual.
| Company | Individual | |
|---|---|---|
| Typical statutory demand threshold | At least £750 | At least £5,000 for bankruptcy proceedings |
| Time to pay or agree terms | 21 days | 21 days |
| Court challenge | Urgent application to restrain a winding-up petition | Application to set aside within 18 days of service |
| If unresolved | HMRC may present a winding-up petition | HMRC may present a bankruptcy petition |
A demand addressed to a director personally concerns the individual, not the company. Personal Self Assessment arrears or a personal guarantee can expose a director separately from the company’s own tax debts.
What Should I Do Immediately After Receiving an HMRC Statutory Demand?
Record exactly how and when the demand reached you, keep every relevant document and decide your response before the deadlines expire. The date of service fixes every deadline that follows.
Start by noting the date, method and address of service. Keep the original demand, the envelope, any delivery record, the email trail and any evidence of hand delivery. A telephone conversation with HMRC does not prove that the matter has been resolved.
Establish whether:
- The debt has been paid or reduced.
- HMRC has agreed payment terms in writing.
- There is a legal basis to challenge the demand.
- The debt is due but cannot be paid.
Then collect:
- The statutory demand and proof of service.
- Tax assessments, penalty notices and payment demands.
- Bank statements, payment confirmations and HMRC account records.
- Letters, emails and notes of calls with HMRC Debt Management.
- Any written payment arrangement.
- Tax appeal documents, including grounds and acknowledgements.
- Current financial information for the company or individual.
The records you need depend on the tax involved. VAT and PAYE arrears usually turn on returns, payroll records and account statements. Corporation Tax and Self Assessment disputes usually turn on the assessment, the calculations and any appeal.
How Long Do I Have to Pay or Challenge an HMRC Statutory Demand?
You have 21 days after service to pay or agree terms with HMRC. An individual who wants to set aside the demand must apply to the court within 18 days of service.
For an individual, section 268 of the Insolvency Act 1986 treats the debtor as appearing unable to pay where:
- The debt is payable immediately.
- A statutory demand in the prescribed form has been served.
- At least three weeks have passed.
- The demand has not been complied with or set aside.
Section 123(1) of the Insolvency Act 1986 provides the equivalent basis for a company winding-up petition. Once the period expires, HMRC does not need further proof that the debtor cannot pay before presenting a petition.
How Does the HMRC Statutory Demand Time Limit Work?
Rule 10.4 of the Insolvency (England and Wales) Rules 2016 states that an individual’s application to set aside a statutory demand must be made within 18 days from the date of service. Filing the application stops the time for complying with the demand from running.
A company generally challenges the position through an urgent application to restrain HMRC from presenting a winding-up petition. The company route differs from the individual bankruptcy procedure, so identify exactly who the demand is addressed to.
Filing a weak application creates its own risk. Under rule 10.5, the court may dismiss an application without notifying HMRC if no sufficient cause is shown. The time for complying with the demand then runs again from the date of dismissal, leaving little time to pay or agree terms.
How Should I Calculate the Service Date?
Calculate the deadlines from the date the demand was served, which may differ from the date printed on it.
- Note the date and method of service.
- Keep the envelope, delivery record or email.
- Check the company’s registered office records or your personal address history.
- Compare those records with HMRC’s correspondence.
- Diarise the 18-day court deadline and the separate 21-day payment deadline.
If a demand was posted to an address you had already left, evidence of your move and any notification sent to HMRC may affect whether service was valid and when the period began.
Can I Set Aside an HMRC Statutory Demand for Disputed Tax?
Yes, where there are properly evidenced grounds to challenge the debt or the demand. An individual applies to set aside the demand. A company with a genuine dispute may need to apply urgently to restrain HMRC from presenting a winding-up petition.
What Counts as a Genuine Dispute?
A genuine dispute concerns whether the debt is due, correctly calculated or still unpaid. The dispute must be genuine and substantial, as recognised in Re a Company (No 0012209 of 1991), and not frivolous, a sham or a delaying tactic.
Potential grounds include:
- A disputed assessment or penalty. HMRC miscalculated income, expenses or reliefs, applied the wrong tax treatment, or imposed a penalty where a reasonable excuse applies.
- Payment not credited. A payment, credit, repayment or adjustment is missing from HMRC’s records.
- An overstated or premature sum. The balance is wrong or not yet due.
- An agreed payment arrangement. HMRC previously agreed Time to Pay in writing and is now departing from it.
- A counterclaim, set-off or cross-demand. For example, a VAT repayment or overpayment that equals or exceeds the debt.
- A defective demand or defective service. Wrong debtor details, a wrong amount or service at the wrong address.
The following are not genuine disputes:
- “I cannot afford to pay.” That is an insolvency problem, not a dispute.
- “HMRC is being unreasonable.” A subjective complaint is not a legal ground.
- “I need more time.” That is a Time to Pay request.
- A trivial quantum point, such as disputing £500 of a £20,000 debt.
Documents carry far more weight than general allegations. A dispute raised only after service may be less persuasive than one supported by earlier correspondence or a properly lodged tax appeal.
Does a Pending Tax Appeal Automatically Stop an HMRC Statutory Demand?
No. A pending appeal to the First-tier Tribunal does not automatically set aside the demand or prevent bankruptcy proceedings.
In Vieira v Revenue And Customs [2017] EWHC 936 (Ch), HMRC served a second statutory demand for £180,757.90 on a minicab driver who traded as a sole trader. He disputed owing more than £2,113, which he had paid. He had lodged an appeal to the First-tier Tribunal on 30 September 2016, out of time and years after the original assessments.
The High Court held that the bankruptcy court could not investigate whether the tax assessments were correct, because challenges to tax assessments belong to the tax tribunal. Its role was limited to deciding whether to adjourn the set-aside application until the appeal was determined. The court said:
“This is a discretion which should be sparingly exercised.”
The court refused to adjourn because the appeal was late and the tribunal had not yet granted permission. HMRC’s own administrative lapses did not excuse the taxpayer’s delay, and his appeal was dismissed.
How Do I Apply to Set Aside an HMRC Statutory Demand?
An individual must apply to the court named on the demand within 18 days of service. Under rule 10.4, the application must identify the debtor, state that it seeks an order setting aside the demand and give the date of the demand.
What Evidence Is Needed?
A focused evidence pack should contain:
- The statutory demand and proof of service.
- A dated chronology of dealings with HMRC.
- Assessments, penalty notices and tax calculations.
- Payment records, bank statements and account reconciliations.
- Evidence of any repayment, credit, overpayment or set-off.
- Written Time to Pay terms.
- Tax appeal documents and supporting professional evidence.
- Documents showing a defect in the demand or service.
The debtor should give a clear factual account in a witness statement and exhibit the important documents. Bare assertions that HMRC is wrong are unlikely to justify court intervention.
What Are the Steps to Challenge the Demand?
- Preserve the demand and service evidence.
- Identify whether the debt is paid, agreed, disputed or affected by another legal issue.
- Gather documents proving that position.
- Prepare the application and supporting witness statement.
- Make three copies of the completed application and post or deliver them to the court named on the demand, within 18 days of service.
- Follow the court’s directions and provide documents to HMRC.
- Prepare for HMRC’s evidence in response and the hearing.
The court may set aside the demand, dismiss the application or adjourn it. If the demand is set aside, HMRC cannot rely on it for a petition, although it may serve a fresh demand or pursue the debt in other proceedings.
A company should take urgent advice on an application to restrain a winding-up petition rather than using the individual set-aside procedure. Court fees and legal costs vary according to the application and the court. If an application fails, the applicant may also face HMRC’s costs.
The court will not set aside a demand simply because the debtor is discussing Time to Pay with HMRC. A formal written agreement is needed.
Can I Pay or Agree Time to Pay With HMRC After a Statutory Demand?
Yes. If the debt is not disputed, paying it or agreeing written payment terms within the 21-day period may resolve the demand.
What If I Can Pay the Debt?
Contact HMRC using the details on the demand and confirm the full balance, including any interest. Pay using the agreed method and keep the payment reference and receipt.
Ask HMRC to confirm in writing how it treats the demand once payment clears. Paying only part of the sum may not resolve the demand unless HMRC confirms the position.
Can I Arrange Time to Pay?
You can ask HMRC for Time to Pay if you accept the debt but cannot pay immediately. HMRC is not obliged to agree, and the 21-day period continues while negotiations take place.
A credible proposal should explain:
- Current cash flow, management accounts and bank evidence.
- The proposed instalment amount and payment period.
- Other creditors and liabilities.
- How ongoing tax obligations will be met.
- Why the business or individual can maintain the arrangement.
If HMRC agrees, obtain written confirmation of the terms and of whether it will refrain from presenting a petition while payments continue. A default can lead to immediate enforcement.
What Happens If I Ignore an HMRC Statutory Demand?
After 21 days, HMRC may present a winding-up petition against a company or a bankruptcy petition against an individual. No further warning may be required.
Winding-Up Petition Against a Company
A winding-up petition asks the court to place the company into liquidation. It can damage the company before any hearing by affecting its credit, banking facilities, suppliers and customers.
A company should act urgently if the debt is genuinely disputed or there is another proper basis to restrain the petition. Challenging a petition after presentation is usually more difficult and more expensive than dealing with the statutory demand.
Directors should take advice before continuing to trade, taking further credit or making payments while insolvency is a concern. If the company cannot pay its debts, their conduct may be examined, and continuing to trade while insolvent can expose them to wrongful trading claims and disqualification proceedings.
Bankruptcy Petition Against an Individual
An unpaid and valid demand can support a bankruptcy petition. Bankruptcy may affect personal assets, income, business interests and credit standing. This is especially important for sole traders, partners and directors with personal tax liabilities.
Informal calls with HMRC do not stop the clock. Unless there is a written agreement or an effective court application, the debtor remains exposed to enforcement.
For advice on protecting a company from insolvency action, our solicitors have also written about insolvency and winding-up petition defence.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can HMRC issue a statutory demand for VAT, PAYE, Corporation Tax or Self Assessment arrears?
+−
Yes. HMRC may use statutory demands for VAT, PAYE and National Insurance arrears, Corporation Tax, Self Assessment, penalties and Accelerated Payment Notices. The type of tax affects the evidence you will need. Payroll records usually matter for PAYE, while returns, assessments and calculations usually matter for VAT, Corporation Tax and Self Assessment.
What if HMRC sent the demand to the wrong address?
+−
Keep the demand, the envelope and evidence of your correct address. For a company, check the registered office records. For an individual, keep evidence of any move and any notification to HMRC. Defective service can be decisive. In Vieira, an earlier bankruptcy order was annulled because the first demand and petition had not been properly served.
Can a statutory demand be served on a director personally?
+−
Yes, where the director has a personal liability, such as Self Assessment arrears or a personal guarantee. The demand is then addressed to the director as an individual, the £5,000 bankruptcy threshold applies, and HMRC may present a bankruptcy petition if it is not paid, agreed or set aside. The company’s own tax debts are a separate matter.
Can I challenge the demand if the amount is wrong or I have already paid some of it?
+−
Yes, if you can prove the error. An accountant’s reconciliation should explain the discrepancy line by line, referring to returns, assessments, bank statements, payment references and HMRC account records. If the error lies in the assessment itself rather than HMRC’s accounting, the tax appeal process may also need to be used.
Do I need a solicitor to apply to set aside an HMRC statutory demand?
+−
No. An individual can apply to the court named on the demand without a solicitor. However, the application must be supported by persuasive evidence and made within 18 days of service. A weak application may be dismissed without a hearing, after which the time to comply starts running again, leaving very little time to pay or reach an agreement.
What happens if HMRC refuses a payment arrangement?
+−
You may need to pay the debt, challenge it where there is a genuine legal basis, or obtain insolvency advice about the wider position. Act immediately, because negotiations do not pause the statutory deadlines unless HMRC confirms its position in writing. A refusal late in the 21-day period can leave almost no room to respond.
Speak to an HMRC Statutory Demand Solicitor Today
An HMRC statutory demand requires urgent action, not further informal discussions. Missing the 18-day set-aside deadline, or allowing 21 days to pass without payment or written terms, can expose an individual to bankruptcy proceedings or a company to a winding-up petition. Once a petition is presented, the cost and difficulty of protecting your position increase sharply.
Our solicitors advise individuals, directors and businesses across England and Wales on HMRC statutory demands, disputed tax debts and insolvency risks. We can review your demand and documents, identify the right response and act within the deadlines that apply to you.
















