Key Takeaways
- “VAT due or paid” has several distinct meanings. Under ordinary accounting, VAT is attributed to the tax point, which is usually the earliest of the supply, the invoice or the payment.
- Businesses in the Cash Accounting Scheme, available where annual taxable supplies excluding VAT do not exceed £1,350,000, account for VAT when they receive or make payment.
- A valid VAT invoice must identify the parties and the supply, and state the tax point, VAT rate, VAT amount and totals. It is the normal evidence for input VAT recovery.
- Pro-forma invoices and incomplete receipts will not support a reclaim. If a supplier fails to invoice, request one in writing and preserve contracts, bank records and correspondence.
- You cannot reclaim VAT shown on an invoice for an exempt or outside-scope supply. Seek a corrected invoice and consider a refund claim against the supplier.
- Our solicitors advise on HMRC decisions where tax points, invoice evidence, exemptions or a Zipvit-type dispute affect your VAT position.
- Go Legal is rated Excellent with over 300 five-star reviews and 5/5 on Trustpilot and Google, placing our solicitors among the best-reviewed litigation lawyers in England and Wales.
When Is VAT Due or Paid, and What Makes a Valid VAT Invoice?
VAT is not always due when your customer pays. Under ordinary VAT accounting, VAT falls into the return for the period in which the tax point occurs. Only businesses using the Cash Accounting Scheme account by reference to payments received and made.
Getting this wrong leads to incorrect VAT returns, rejected input VAT claims and disputes with HMRC. The invoice matters just as much as the timing. A customer can pay VAT in full and still be unable to reclaim it if it does not hold a compliant VAT invoice.
What Is VAT Due or Paid? Five Different Meanings
“VAT due or paid” can describe five different questions. Each has a different effect on a VAT return, an invoice dispute or an HMRC enquiry.
| Meaning | What it decides | Practical example | Evidence to check | Legal source |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| VAT due on a supply | When the supplier accounts for output tax | A contractor completes work but has not been paid | Supply, invoice and payment dates | HMRC VAT Notice 700 |
| VAT due on a VAT return | The net position after output tax and recoverable input tax, subject to the accounting scheme and adjustments | A business offsets VAT on purchases against VAT charged to customers | VAT return, purchase invoices and sales invoices | HMRC VAT Notice 700 |
| VAT due when payment is made | Whether cash accounting changes the timing of VAT entries | A qualifying business accounts for VAT after receiving payment | Cash Accounting Scheme records and payment evidence | HMRC VAT Notice 700 |
| VAT shown as due on an invoice | What the supplier has actually charged, which may be wrong if the supply is exempt, zero-rated, outside scope or incorrectly valued | An invoice includes VAT for an exempt supply | Invoice, contract and VAT treatment | Value Added Tax Act 1994, Schedule 11 and the VAT Regulations 1995 |
| VAT due or paid as evidence | Whether VAT was genuinely charged, paid and recoverable, or merely included in a price | A contract price may have included an amount said to be VAT | Contract, invoices, payment records and supplier’s VAT treatment | Zipvit Ltd v Commissioners for Her Majesty’s Revenue and Customs |
The supplier’s output tax is not automatically the same as the customer’s recoverable input tax. The supplier may owe VAT to HMRC on an invoice that the customer cannot use to reclaim anything.
Current VAT invoicing rules are principally found in Schedule 11 to the Value Added Tax Act 1994 and regulations 13 to 20 of the VAT Regulations 1995. Schedule 11 allows regulations to require a VAT invoice containing prescribed particulars of the supply, the supplier, the customer and the VAT charged. Regulation 13 imposes the core obligation to provide one.
When Is VAT Due: Supply, Invoice or Payment?
Under ordinary accounting, VAT is due at the tax point, not when the money arrives. The tax point is usually the earliest of the supply, the issue of a VAT invoice or the receipt of payment.
The basic tax point for goods is normally the date they are dispatched or collected. For services, it is the date the service is performed, which usually means when all the work except invoicing is complete.
An actual tax point arises earlier if the supplier issues a VAT invoice or receives payment before the basic tax point. That earlier event fixes the VAT accounting date for the amount invoiced or paid.
Preparing an invoice internally does not create a tax point. The invoice must be sent or given to the customer. An invoice issued more than 14 days after the basic tax point will not generally move the tax point unless HMRC has approved an extension.
A supplier must normally issue the VAT invoice within 30 days of the tax point, unless an earlier invoice has itself created the tax point.
What Is the Difference Between the VAT Tax Point and Cash Accounting?
The tax point governs ordinary accounting. The Cash Accounting Scheme replaces it with the dates money is received and paid.
Under ordinary accounting, a business cannot generally delay accounting for VAT because its customer has not paid. Under the Cash Accounting Scheme, output VAT is accounted for when payment is received, and input VAT is claimed only once the business has paid its own supplier.
The scheme is available where annual taxable supplies, excluding VAT, do not exceed £1,350,000. Preparing management accounts on a cash basis is not the same as being in the VAT Cash Accounting Scheme. Assuming otherwise is one of the most common causes of under-declared VAT.
If payment timing or tax points have affected your past VAT returns, our HMRC tax disputes solicitors can advise on correcting the position and responding to any HMRC challenge.
What Must a Valid VAT Invoice Contain in 2026?
A valid VAT invoice must contain the particulars HMRC prescribes and accurately reflect the supply. It supports both the supplier’s output tax position and the customer’s input VAT claim.
When Must a VAT-Registered Business Issue a VAT Invoice?
A VAT-registered business must normally issue a VAT invoice when it makes a taxable UK supply to another VAT-registered person. It generally does not need to issue one to a consumer or a non-VAT-registered business, although ordinary commercial invoicing practice may still apply. A VAT invoice is also not required for zero-rated supplies.
Registration status therefore matters. For 2026 to 2027, the VAT registration threshold remains £90,000 and the deregistration threshold £88,000. The standard rate remains 20%, the reduced rate 5% and the zero rate 0%.
A full VAT invoice should include:
- A unique and sequential invoice number.
- The issue date.
- The tax point or date of supply, if different from the issue date.
- The supplier’s name, address and VAT registration number.
- The customer’s name and address, and VAT number where relevant.
- A description sufficient to identify the goods or services.
- The quantity or extent of the supply.
- The unit price excluding VAT, and any discounts.
- The VAT rate.
- The amount payable excluding VAT.
- The total VAT chargeable in sterling.
- The total amount including VAT.
- Any required wording for reverse charge, self-billing, margin scheme or cash accounting supplies.
An invoice can be good enough to chase payment yet still fail as VAT evidence if it lacks the tax point, the VAT number or a meaningful description.
When Can Simplified or Electronic Invoices Be Used?
A simplified VAT invoice may be used for retail supplies of £250 or less including VAT, subject to HMRC’s conditions. It must still show the supplier’s name, address and VAT registration number, the tax point, a description of the supply and, for each VAT rate, the VAT-inclusive total and the rate.
PDF and EDI invoices are currently permitted where the recipient agrees. The current rules do not require any particular technology, system or platform.
Modified invoices, retailers’ invoices, self-billing and reverse-charge supplies carry additional requirements, set out in HMRC VAT Notice 700 and Notice 700/12.
Can I Reclaim Input VAT Without a Valid VAT Invoice?
Generally, no. A valid VAT invoice is the normal evidence for an input VAT claim under the VAT Regulations 1995, and without one a business may be unable to reclaim the VAT it was charged.
The invoice supports the existence, value and VAT treatment of the supply, but it is not conclusive. HMRC may refuse a claim where the transaction is fictitious or incorrectly described, even if the invoice looks complete.
A pro-forma invoice cannot be used to reclaim input VAT, even if it contains every detail required on a VAT invoice. A proper VAT invoice must be issued once the supply or payment takes place. Purchase orders and receipts without VAT details do not support recovery either.
What If a Supplier Will Not Issue a VAT Invoice?
If a supplier will not provide an invoice:
- Ask in writing for a compliant VAT invoice.
- Keep the request and any response.
- Preserve the contract, purchase order, delivery records, bank evidence and correspondence.
- Check the supplier’s VAT registration and the VAT treatment of the supply.
- Consider whether alternative evidence can be presented to HMRC.
- Take advice before submitting or maintaining a disputed claim.
HMRC may consider alternative evidence, but only in limited circumstances. You will need to show that the supply occurred, that it took place in the United Kingdom, that it was taxable, that the supplier was a taxable person, that it was made to your business and that you intended to use it for business purposes.
Acceptance is discretionary, not a right. HMRC will look at the quality of the evidence, whether you took reasonable steps to obtain an invoice and whether there is any fraud or risk to revenue.
What Happens If VAT Is Charged Incorrectly or an Invoice Is Missing?
Incorrect VAT treatment creates separate risks for the supplier and the customer.
If a supplier issues an invoice showing VAT for an exempt or outside-scope supply, the customer cannot reclaim that VAT, even though it has paid it. The supplier must account to HMRC for the VAT shown on the invoice unless the invoice is corrected. If the supplier refuses to correct it, the customer’s remedy is a refund negotiation or a claim against the supplier. You may find our guide on commercial disputes useful if it reaches that stage.
If a supplier never issues a VAT invoice, the customer cannot reclaim input VAT even where VAT was built into the price, unless HMRC accepts alternative evidence. A late invoice will not move a tax point that has already occurred, but the customer still needs it to support the reclaim.
Self-billing allows the customer to issue the invoice on the supplier’s behalf, which requires a clear written arrangement and matching records on both sides. Under the reverse charge, the customer accounts for VAT instead of the supplier. It applies to certain supplies, including some construction services, energy and mobile phones.
Businesses must keep VAT invoices and records for at least six years. Missing records can lead to disallowed input VAT claims and penalties.
What Does the Zipvit Case Mean for VAT Due or Paid?
The Zipvit litigation shows that “VAT due or paid” cannot be read in isolation from the contract, the invoices and the payment evidence.
In Zipvit Ltd v Commissioners for Her Majesty’s Revenue and Customs, the supplier did not charge VAT because it believed the supply was exempt. The contract stated that the price was payable plus VAT, if any. Zipvit sought to deduct input VAT on the basis that the price it paid should be treated as including VAT, although the supplier’s invoices did not show VAT as charged.
The Supreme Court did not decide the point itself. It referred questions to the Court of Justice, including whether the price paid could be treated as including VAT for input VAT recovery purposes. The court explained:
“After full argument, the court has decided that neither the ‘due or paid’ issue nor the invoice issue can be regarded as acte clair, and that a reference should be made to the Court of Justice to ask the questions set out at the end of this judgment.”
“Acte clair” means the answer is so obvious that no reference is needed. The Supreme Court’s view that neither question was obvious shows how finely balanced these disputes are. The issues were whether VAT was actually due or paid, and whether alternative evidence could stand in for an invoice that did not show VAT.
For businesses, the practical lesson is that a clause such as “plus VAT if applicable” shows commercial intention only. It does not prove that recoverable VAT was charged, paid or supported by a compliant VAT invoice.
What Will Mandatory VAT E-Invoicing Mean for Businesses?
From 1 April 2029, VAT-registered persons will need to issue and receive VAT invoices as e-invoices unless a specific exemption applies, according to the government’s roadmap for e-invoicing implementation. Exemptions are expected for some digitally excluded persons. The current rules permit electronic invoices but do not require them.
The obligation is aimed at supplies where a VAT invoice is already required, principally taxable supplies between VAT-registered businesses. The government has identified Peppol as the core interoperability framework. Detailed technical requirements, exemptions and transitional rules will be set through legislation and HMRC guidance.
E-invoicing should create a stronger digital audit trail and reduce arguments about when invoices were issued or received. It also creates a new risk. An invoice in the wrong format, or one that a system cannot retrieve during an HMRC enquiry, may become the new missing-invoice dispute.
Businesses should:
- Map current invoicing and approval processes.
- Identify the systems used by key suppliers and customers.
- Review invoice fields and tax-point controls.
- Assess whether any exemption may apply.
- Review software contracts and upgrade requirements.
- Monitor legislation and HMRC guidance as the deadline approaches.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is VAT due when an invoice is issued, when work is completed or when the customer pays?
+−
Under ordinary accounting, VAT is due at the tax point, usually the earliest of completing the supply, issuing a VAT invoice or receiving payment. It does not depend on when the customer pays unless the business uses the Cash Accounting Scheme. An unpaid invoice therefore still needs to go on the VAT return for the period of its tax point.
Can I reclaim input VAT if my supplier has ceased trading?
+−
A supplier’s closure does not remove the evidence requirement. A valid VAT invoice remains the starting point, so try any liquidator or former director first and keep a record of your requests. If no invoice can be obtained, HMRC may consider contracts, bank records and correspondence proving the taxable supply was made to your business.
What should I do if an invoice does not show the supplier’s VAT number?
+−
Ask the supplier in writing for a corrected invoice and keep the request. The VAT registration number is a required detail, and its absence gives HMRC grounds to challenge the claim. Other records can help explain the transaction, but they do not automatically replace a compliant VAT invoice.
Can a deposit or advance payment affect when VAT is accounted for?
+−
Yes. Under ordinary accounting, a payment received before the basic tax point creates an actual tax point for the amount paid. The supplier must account for output VAT on the deposit in the period it is received, even if the goods have not been dispatched or the services have not been completed.
Can incorrect VAT advice from an accountant lead to a professional negligence claim?
+−
Potentially, where the advice caused financial loss. The key questions are what the adviser was engaged to do, what advice was given, what a competent adviser would have said and what loss followed. Our guide to professional negligence claims against accountants and tax advisers explains how these claims are assessed.
When Should I Seek Advice on a VAT Invoice or HMRC Dispute?
Seek specialist advice as soon as a VAT issue involves an HMRC enquiry, assessment, penalty, disallowed claim or commercial loss. Common warning signs include:
- HMRC has rejected input VAT because an invoice is missing or incomplete.
- HMRC says the supply was exempt, zero-rated or outside scope.
- A supplier refuses to issue or correct a VAT invoice.
- You have issued invoices showing VAT on supplies that may not be taxable.
- Payment dates were used when ordinary tax-point rules applied.
- You paid a price believing it included VAT, but the supplier did not account for VAT.
- A self-billing or reverse-charge arrangement has produced inconsistent records.
- Incorrect advice from an accountant or tax adviser may have caused financial loss.
Preserve the original invoice, contract, payment evidence and correspondence before asking anyone to correct a document. The order in which documents were created and changed can become decisive evidence in an HMRC enquiry or a claim against a supplier.
Delay rarely helps. An uncorrected error can recur in every subsequent VAT return, and evidence becomes harder to gather once suppliers move on or cease trading.
Our HMRC tax disputes team acts for businesses, directors and professionals across England and Wales in HMRC enquiries, appeals to the First-tier Tribunal (Tax) and judicial review of HMRC decisions. We also handle disputed VAT claims, supplier invoice disputes and related professional negligence claims. To discuss your position, book a free consultation or call us on 0207 459 4037.
















